Brett McCracken on Becoming Slaves to Our Phones, Why AI Will Make Us Dumber, and AI Girlfriends

The Dan Leibrandt Show · Episode 3November 2, 2026 · 61 min
Brett McCracken, slaves to our phones

Episode Summary

The summary and key moments are written by AI from the episode transcript.

Brett McCracken is a senior editor at The Gospel Coalition, the author of The Wisdom Pyramid and The Wisdom of Sleep, and co-editor of Scrolling Ourselves to Death, which revisits Neil Postman’s Amusing Ourselves to Death forty years later. Dan opens with a statistic from that book, a 62 percent rise in the suicide rate for 10 to 24 year olds between 2007, the year the iPhone debuted, and 2021, and asks what phones are doing to people.

McCracken doesn’t argue for throwing phones away. His first rule for discernment is to do less of it, and his Wisdom Pyramid treats phones, social media and AI like fats, oils and sweets, fine in small portions but harmful as a staple. He explains why brain rot is real cognitive atrophy, and why AI, which offloads thinking, could speed it up.

He uses AI for home repairs and travel tips, but warns of a slippery slope toward asking it for life and relationship advice, and says an AI companion is no substitute for a fellow image bearer of God. He and Dan compare notes on how flattering chatbots are, including Dan’s story of ChatGPT telling him what he wanted to hear while he waited for the northern lights in Iceland. They also talk about what post-truth means, why vibes now beat arguments, and McCracken’s hope that Christians can offer clarity in an anxious age. He closes with his new book, The Wisdom of Sleep, and the idea that limits are gifts, not obstacles.

Key Moments

  • 01:02What McCracken sees behind the worldwide rise in teen depression, anxiety and loneliness
  • 14:16The Wisdom Pyramid, from the Bible at the base to phones, social media and AI at the top
  • 17:44Why brain rot is real cognitive atrophy, and why AI could make it worse
  • 26:38Why chatbots talk like people, and where AI companions are heading
  • 34:59Why AI is built to flatter you and never tell you you're wrong
  • 46:00Why vibes now matter more than arguments
Read the full transcriptHide the transcript

Full Transcript

00:00Intro

00:00Dan Leibrandt

Brett McCracken, welcome to the Dan Leibrandt Show.

00:03Brett McCracken

Yeah, thanks for having me, Dan.

00:05Dan Leibrandt

Of course. So, Brett, you're a senior editor at The Gospel Coalition. You've written for the Wall Street Journal and the Washington Post. And you just came out with a new book, The Wisdom of Sleep. But I want to start with your book from last year, which is Scrolling Ourselves to Death. And I was just reading it over the past few days, and there's one stat that really stuck out to me, and I wanted to mention it here, and I'll quote. Between 2001 and 2007, the suicide rate for kids aged 10 to 24 was fairly stable. But since 2007, the year the iPhone debuted, it has skyrocketed, rising 62% between 2007 and 2021. Now, around this, first, of course, this is just appalling. I can't even believe this. Why are phones making people kill themselves?

00:33Smartphones and the youth mental health crisis

01:02Brett McCracken

Yeah, I mean I think that's the that's the reckoning that we are experiencing right now in culture, not only in America, but all over the world. You know, the this technology is global and if you look across the world right now, like statistics on Teen suicide, depression, anxiety, loneliness, like all of these things are increasing all over the world. And the only commonality that can explain it, the only thing that has been true all over the world over the last 15 years is what? It's the introduction of this new technology, this mobile phone, smartphone technology. So figuring out exactly what is happening there in terms of that connection, what about the way we use these devices is leading to such poor mental health, such poor relational health. There's also a global coupling crisis, it's been called, of people not dating as much anymore, not getting married, not having babies as much as they used to. And there's a lot of theories, which I think are correct, that that as well is tied to the digital isolation that these devices are creating, where, you know, we can now just retreat into our little bubbles of individuate individual consumption of media and feeds and you know podcasts like whatever like podcasts are great but when it becomes just another thing you consume as an individual in your own little bubble of headphones and devices it becomes problematic right it isolates you from other people and it pushes you further into yourself which is not a healthy thing to happen so there's a lot of dynamics that are are that are going on here, but I think what we do know is there's a lot of alarm bells going off. And that's why we wrote that's why we put this book together, Scrolling Ourselves to Death, to help to help Christians especially just be more aware of that and to be more careful in thinking about how we use these technologies and how we can be more wise about how we use them.

03:26What Neil Postman would say about today

03:26Dan Leibrandt

For sure. I earlier this year, I'd I read three of Neil Postman's books, Amusing Ourselves to Death, Technopoly, End of Education. Brilliant writer. And it's so cool that you made this book as a corollary to that as a fortieth year anniversary. And I wanted to ask you, if Neil Postman was alive today, I believe he died in two thousand one or two thousand three. What do you think he would say about society now?

03:51Brett McCracken

Yeah, I mean I think I don't think he would be I don't think he would be enthusiastic or optimistic about the direction of society. In many ways what he wrote about back in the eighties or early nineties about technology, which It was a pretty dire outlook even back then. And it comes through in his writing, you know, Technopoly is a book that's kind of a prophetic warning about the way that technology is pitched to us as a tool of efficiency. It's gonna like make your life easier. It's you know, it's just it's just a tool. But his argument in that book is that soon it becomes a kind of idol in your life and it uses you, right? You're the tool. Like it uses you more than you use it and it transforms you. So if that were if that was true, you know, in the nineties how much more true is that today? And so I think he would look at today's technologies and just basically reaffirm what he was arguing about technology decades ago. But I think it's just to the nth degree now, which is kind of why we wanted to revisit Amusing Ourselves to Death 40 years later with the Scrolling Ourselves to Death book, because I feel like his warnings and hit his like careful critical. Posture towards technology is more needed than ever today. Like we need to Christians and just everyday people, we need to adopt that kind of postman type posture of caution and care and just think a little bit more deeply than we do about how media and technology changes us in ways that we can't often see while it's happening. That's the that's the power of technology. You don't there's kind of the obvious problems with technology, like you know, let's say with the internet, like one of the obvious problems that everyone can. Can agree as a problem is internet pornography and the ease with which even young people can access that. And that is a problem. But what Postman does is he kind of goes a few levels deeper and looks at those aspects of technology that change us in negative ways, on a more s in a more subtle way. It changes the way we think, the way that we process ideas and it challenges the very notion of truth and how and how do we know what is true. So that's kind of what we're trying to do with this book for Christians is to get more more Christians thinking a few layers deeper about the technologies that they're using.

06:40Dan Leibrandt

Okay. Yeah, that makes sense. I don't believe that you're li you completely cross off technology. I think there there can be a balance. So what is that balance for you? What is the right balance?

06:52Brett McCracken

We do we do sing the praises of the Amish several times in the book. So some there are moments in Scrolling Ourselves to Death where you could get that impression that, you know, we're arguing just like chuck your phone in the trash and go live on a farm. But no, I mean ultimately my approach in my books and in all of my writing about technology is more kind of It's unrealistic to put the genie back in the bottle with these technologies, like for better or worse, this is the world we live in. There are good things that can come out of these technologies. The internet has done a lot of great things in our world. And the ministry that I work for, The Gospel Coalition, is one of those things. We use the internet to share Christian resources. This podcast that we're having this conversation on is another example, right? So there are good things, and I think we can have a both and approach as Christians where we try to use technology wisely and in redemptive ways, ideally, in ways that kind of bless people and bring spiritual health, perhaps. And at the same time, we can't be naive to the many ways that these technologies are forming us individually in potentially harmful ways, forming society at large in very problematic ways. The all the different metrics of mental health that we that I mentioned earlier is just one thing. Political partisanship, the way that like the algorithm has sown seeds of division like we've never seen before because everyone is living in their own algorithmic bubble that's a little bit different than everyone else's. So we have to be aware of those problematic dynamics as Christians. And so what we're arguing in this book is not just a simplistic like, you know, just don't use technology. It's rather like how can we use these technologies in a very sober-minded, careful way? And maybe it does look like using them at a lot, you know. Lower rates than we currently do. S one thing I often say when people ask me how do you how do you use the internet with discernment? Or like how do you like watch Netflix with discernment or something? One thing I always say is just do less of it. That's the first step. Like all of us would probably be better off if we just watch Netflix a little bit less than we do. Go on the internet a little bit less than we do, right? P part of the problem of the malformation is just the sheer amount, like the glut. You know, we are just we are gluttonous when it comes to like scrolling and consuming content. So part of Christian discernment in the digital age is just being willing to like, you know, go offline more than we do. And I have a hat that I should have worn it for this interview. It says, read books and touch grass.

10:04Dan Leibrandt

Ha...

10:05Brett McCracken

And if we just all did that more, read a physical book and go touch grass, go out in nature, you know, and this gets at what I'm arguing in The Wisdom Pyramid, like there are other things that you can do in your life than just scrolling. And those other things are probably going to be more nourishing for your overall health. So we have to be discerning in the amount of how we consume digital media as well as how we go about doing it when we do do it.

10:34Is endless scrolling a form of gluttony

10:34Dan Leibrandt

Totally agree. And a point or really a whole thing that you've owned is the analogy of consuming information to eating food. I and as you mentioned, glut. A lot of people think of gluttony as in eating too much or maybe drinking too much, like maybe too much alcohol or something. But a lot of people don't think of it in terms of information. But it seems like that is clearly the case now. So I just to be clear on that. Do you think that consuming tons of information, let's say scrolling for three hours straight, is that gluttony?

11:10Brett McCracken

Absolutely. And I make that argument explicitly in my book, The Wisdom Pyramid, which that whole book is basically like making a parallel argument to physical health in large part depends on your diet. You know, just like the food pyramid was guidance for like the proper proportions of food groups that would help you become physically healthy. What I'm arguing in that book, The Wisdom Pyramid, is that the same is true of our spiritual health, it really does depend on what's coming into us, what's feeding our soul, what ideas, what forms of experience and knowledge. So being mindful of kind of what makes up our diet, so to speak, are we getting like disproportionate amounts? Of our diet from TikTok, you know, that's probably not gonna do a body good. I mean, that's probably not gonna do a soul good, right? It would be the equivalent of eating only cookies and brownies for your diet, you know. It's not gonna end well for your physical health. But so many of us, if we're honest, we are kind of like on a mostly junk food diet when it comes to media and ideas and news consumption. And it's we're just gorging on brain rot junk food content. And that's what's making us so spiritually sick. That's what's making us so foolish. You know, that's why we call it brain rot. We can feel our brains rotting as we consume it. So we need to do the opposite. We need to like think about what makes up a balanced, nutritious diet f that is good for our soul in this age of information gluttony, information overstimulation, where it's really easy to binge the unhealthy stuff. But we need to know where to look for like healthier things to consume. So that's what I'm trying to do in The Wisdom Pyramid.

13:10The Wisdom Pyramid explained

13:11Dan Leibrandt

Yeah. So around that, maybe for people that haven't read the book, can you briefly describe what is the ideal pyramid regarding like the information you're consuming?

13:26Brett McCracken

Yeah, it's a very visual concept. So, it's I would just encourage if anyone's listening to this and is curious, just like Google The Wisdom Pyramid and you'll s you'll instantly find like the image and that'll help that'll help you. But just to describe it quickly, you know, just like the food pyramid, the old food pyramid, I think it's different. I think last year they released a new food pyramid that was like inverted. It's kind of con it's confusing. I can't quite figure it out, but the old classic food. Pyramid if you can picture it. It was like the bread group at the bottom and then like going up, you know, it was gradually like less important for your overall diet. Still valuable, like vegetables and fruits, I think, were the next level up, and then like protein and meat and dairy. Were the next level and then at the top, in the smallest part of the pyramid, the food pyramid, it was fats, oils, and sweets. And the guidance there is use sparingly. So with my wisdom pyramid, I'm basically ripping off that concept. So for my wisdom pyramid, going from the bottom up, so going for them from the most important for your diet to the least, I have the Bible at the bottom. So that's like the staple of a healthy diet, because it's God's an infallible word. It's the only, it's the only source of nourishment for us that is not going to introduce toxins, right? It's just a perfect thing, right? It's God's perfect word. And then I have the church, and then I have nature. So God's creation, which is so good for our wisdom. And that chapter in the book was so fun to write because, you know, there really is an unappreciated value for touching grass and going outside. And being off screens. And I think it makes sense because this is God's handiwork, right? He created it. So we should pick up wisdom by being in his creation and observing it carefully. So then I have like things like books, reading books, physical books, ideally, beauty, the arts, experiences of you know, artistic excellence and beauty. And then at the very top of The Wisdom Pyramid, in the fats or oils and sweets category. That's where I put the phone and social media and like AI. Like yes, it's there, it can be a part of your diet, but it needs to be in a smaller portion than it probably currently occupies in your diet. And we if we have it in a in a less kind of prominent place, it'll serve our overall health. But when we when we flip it and we functionally kind of live everyday life with our phone and the internet as like the staple of our wisdom diet, like that's when things go wrong. That's when we kind of lose our minds and become fools. And we're seeing it happen, right? You can see it happen in your own life. But there's been seasons in my own life where I've been on my phone more than I should and I've been like just binging kind of junk food content. And I can literally feel my brain rotting. I can feel my soul atrophy. I can feel myself becoming less wise in real time. And so that that was the wake-up call for me, I don't know, eight years ago when I first started thinking about writing The Wisdom Pyramid. Like I was seeing in my own life in the digital era, I was seeing myself become more foolish. And I wanted to relearn kind of how to be wise and nothing, nothing I'm arguing in The Wisdom Pyramid is particularly new in terms of like God's word, you know, the church. Creation, these are ancient sources of wisdom, but I think we need to be re reminded of their nourishing value in today's digital world.

13:50Dan Leibrandt

Yeah, I think so.

17:29Is brain rot real

17:30Dan Leibrandt

Yeah. Yeah, you mentioned the term brain rot and people use it jokingly, but it as seems like you believe, I believe as well that it actually is rotting your brain. Like this is really, really bad for you.

17:44Brett McCracken

Yeah, I mean it's like empirically shown like neuroscientists, like brain scientists have have clearly shown that this is happening in the internet era. The internet is rewiring our brains, and it's called cognitive atrophy, where like when your brain operates all day, every day on a mile wide, inch deep level, which is so much how we operate on social media feeds and TikTok. You naturally lose the muscle, right? Like just like when you when you are an athlete and you like don't go to the gym for a long period of time, your muscles start to atrophy, right? Like you keep your muscles both physically and intellectually by practicing, by being in practice, right? And the same is true with like thinking well. Like if we if we don't read books, if we get out of that habit, like you'll become a poorer reader. And that's the real concerning thing about AI, just shift to a related but really big current topic, AI. The cognitive atrophy has already been in motion for the last like 15 years in the internet era. It's been well documented. You can read Nicholas Carr's book, The Shallows, for more on that. And that book is like 15 years old now. So he was kind of early to observe this. So we're 15 years deeper into the internet age. So the problems he highlighted in The Shallows are even more pronounced. But now we have AI, and AI is essentially a technology of offloading brain tasks, right? All the hard things that we struggle to do, you know, you can now just ask Claude or ChatGPT to do it for you. Whether it's like summarize a book for me. I don't have time or energy to read it, summarize a book for me. Or any number that cognitive offloading that we now do regularly with AI is only going to make us dumber, right? Because we're gonna, our muscles of thinking critically are gonna become out of practice because robots are doing the thinking for us. And that's that should concern us, right? As Christians, we should be concerned by that because part of how we honor God, I believe, part of how we are stewards of the bodies and the minds He's given us, is that we actually care about thinking well and thinking critically. We don't want it we don't wanna just like let robots be the ones who do all that hard work for us. So there's a lot to say talk about with AI and we can talk about that more if you want to, Dan, but yeah, I think the reality of like our brain rot is real. It's not just a hashtag brain rot catchphrase like and I think Gen Z, the way that Gen Z talks about brain rot, it's I describe it as like a both it's both irony, it's like self-aware irony, but also like a sincere cry for help. Like I feel Gen Z is like, yeah, yeah, yeah, this is brain rot. Like everything I'm doing right now on TikTok, it's brain rot. I know it's brain rot, but like I don't know how to live any differently. Can you please help me? Can you please show me how to like get out of this cycle? Because digital natives don't know how to live any differently. They've grown up in a world where they're tethered to their phone. Social interaction is done through phones and screens. Like the algorithm is just all that they've ever known, really. So they recognize that it's not good for them. And there's even statistics about this where like the majority of like Gen Z and Gen Alpha. Digital natives, they will say, I know my phone is bad for me. I know social media is bad for me. But at the same time, they can't stop. They don't know how to quit because what else is there to do, right? Like they don't know. They don't know how to do those old things like going outside without a device and just being still, being still for five minutes without a device is a really hard thing for like a twenty year old person to do today. And that's scary, right? So these problems are real and we all feel it. And as Christians we need to not be passive about it, but we need to figure out how to make changes.

18:47Why AI will make us dumber

22:24Dan Leibrandt

Yeah, definitely. It's funny because with social media and the whole doom scrolling thing, whether it's almost like everything's a doom scroll. It's Uber Eats and Netflix, scrolling on everywhere. And it was kind of information glut, you get information fatigue and it's too much. And I can almost see people kind of liking AI because it's like, well, at least now I don't have this information fatigue or decision fatigue, because now the AI can decide for me in the super complex world.

22:54Brett McCracken

Yeah, for sure. Yeah. I think that is honestly one of the most insidious things about AI that it really does play directly to that pain point that we feel. Like the internet is such an overwhelming place. We feel overwhelmed. Like I we feel how can I even begin to navigate all of the options like, you know, like for example, one thing that I use AI for in my own life is like handyman tasks around the house. I'm not like naturally gifted in that. So I need to I used to consult YouTube for that. Now I just add ask Claude. I'll take a picture of like the problem that I need to fix, like and I'll g I'll say how would how give me a step-by-step tutorial about how to fix this. And boom, you know, without me having to like go hunting on Google or YouTube for like the best tutorial, it c it consolidates all of the best resources in one kind of nice, nicely packaged answer. And that's really helpful and that's really appealing. And I also use it sometimes for like when I'm traveling in another city and I'm unfamiliar with it. Like I was in Cleveland last weekend and I had like two hours free. So I asked AI, like, can you just recommend like three things for me to do in my two hours in Cleveland? I like good food, I like culture, like you know, and boom, it gave me some great recommendations. So I it saved me time of having to go hunting on Yelp for good food and coffee or whatever. So it's undeniable that AI is super helpful and it's a super like time-saving thing. But I think that's precisely why we have to be so careful with it because once we get in the habit of like going to AI for things like restaurant recommendations or like handyman tasks, it's kind of a slippery slope. Like soon we'll ask it about. Bigger things. Soon we'll ask it about life advice. You know, like I'm struggling with this big decision in my life. Here are the options I'm considering. Can you help me like figure out this problem? Soon we might ask it about like relationship advice. That's where I think it's gonna be problematic because. It's AI is already proving itself to be very helpful and you know very fast and easy to use. But there's some things in life where the friction and kind of the processing and the time and the difficulty of like calling up a real friend and like getting time on the calendar to like go out to coffee and to process with them this life decision or this relationship struggle that you're having. Like that, there's more friction on that path, but I think that's the wiser path. And the low friction, kind of just take out your phone and ask Claude approach isn't the best approach for some of the most important things in life.

26:08AI girlfriends, friends and therapists

26:08Dan Leibrandt

Yeah. Yeah. I'm about the same in regards to how you think about that. Like I you know, I need to use don't need to, but I use it for my work and some other kind of more technical things, like you're saying, maybe think fixing things around the house. But yeah, I think specifically when it's relational, when you start treating it like a friend or a girlfriend or a therapist or a mentor, you're kinda like you shouldn't blur the lines between like things that you should ask a human for. It's like, but you're asking the AI for.

26:36Brett McCracken

Sure. Well, and it's just interesting that like the even Claude, right? Like they ch Anthropic chose they chose to name their AI with a human name, right? Claude. And the answers that AI comes comes up with, it uses personal pronouns. It uses I and me. So It's really just it's just a robot, it's just zeros and ones. So it should be using third person language in the way that it answers our prompts, but instead It uses this personal language, and s and I think that's by design, because I think these tech companies, they know that humans are relational beings, and we are going to probably become more addicted to these large language model programs if we start to feel like it's a friend, right? And that's even like Mark Zuckerberg's like explicit vision with Meta. He's talked about how he thinks the future is gonna be like every individual person has. Has their own little personal AI. Companion friend who just kind of exists in their brain or some somehow is like always with you and you can just like process everything with your AI friend and like they will help you do every aspect of life together. And that just feels really dystopian to me, to me, because if we're already struggling with social awkwardness and like social isolation, I mentioned the coupling crisis, people getting date dating and getting married at lower rates than ever before. If that's already a problem, it's just gonna get worse when we have AI to fill or to you know give us the illusion of filling our relational need. It's not really gonna fill that need, I feel like it'll scratch that itch a little bit like when you're lonely, but an AI companion is not a suitable replacement for a fellow image bearer of God in a in a human being. And that's really concerning to me. And that this is something that I think every pastor, every church leader needs to be preparing for. How do you how do you disciple people in the need for like real embodied human relationships at a time when digital friends, AI friends are gonna become more and more normal? I think I saw a statistic about like already 25% of Gen Z people in a poll. 25% of Gen Z said that they expect AI companions will be kind of a suitable replacement for girlfriends or boyfriends in the future. Like so that's pr that's concerning, right? That there's already an idea that that's a suitable alternative, really. But you can see how we got here, right? Because we've already had twenty years of internet pornography where you know, digital fantasies kind of have replaced real-world romantic relationships. We've already had, you know, 20 years almost of social media where like digital friendships, just people who your photos, people who, you know, post a comment on Facebook, that that be has become kind of a replacement for offline friendships. So the path has already been paved for this, and I think AI companions and AI girlfriends and boyfriends are is just kind of the next logical step, sadly.

29:29Dan Leibrandt

Cheese.

30:24Elon Musk's Optimus robots and AI companions

30:24Dan Leibrandt

Yeah, I see that as well. It's sh it's unfortunate. And I don't see that fully getting manifested until there's actually physical robots and that's where things like I'm really f worried about that and I...

30:36Brett McCracken

That's coming. Have you seen Elon Musk's like Android like robot that that he's prepeti prep preparing to launch? So that's coming for sure in the next like five years, I think.

30:41Dan Leibrandt

Yeah, the Optimus bots. Yeah, yeah. So it's gonna be scary. We'll need to maybe do a another podcast to reconvene on that. And yeah, the other point I was gonna mention, which of course you've you've mentioned this in your your books and such, is that these companies, you know, it's not like a government organization or it's not like a fund project. They are for profit, they are maximally profit-seeking. So the way they make profit, of course, is by getting as much of our attention as possible. And that's with the social platforms and with the AI platforms. And like you mentioned, they're willing to do something that I would deem unethical of acting like a an AI that's not a person that's yet acting personal. I see that as unethical, but yeah, they're willing to do it to maximize profits. And I wanted to ask you around that, because you're well versed in both these topics. What do you think? Is more damaging or will be more damaging social media and the scrolling or large language models like ChatGPT and the getting the answers.

30:57Is AI more dangerous than social media

31:57Brett McCracken

It's hard to it's hard to know. I mean, I think social media was massively harmful and we're seeing like ev every week there's like a new lawsuit that Facebook has to pay like fifteen billion to this plaintiff and like twenty five billion to this one. Like so our society is coming to grips finally with the all the damage that has been done by social media, especially for young people. But I mean, honestly, and I don't wanna sound like a downer Debbie or like you know overly ominous here, but I do think AI is such a powerful technology. The sheer power of it and the potential that it has is I think it's just a lot greater than social media. Social media was a powerful technology that was unleashed on the world, you know, 20 years ago. AI is like powerful in a whole nother level, right? Like it is and we're just in the dial-up era of AI. We are in the era of AI right now that like dial up internet in the late nineties was to in terms of how far the internet has come since then, think about if we're already kind of wowed by what AI can do, you know, like creating songs in two seconds that sound like beautiful human songs or like movie, Elon Musk just launched his version of the Odyssey that was like AI made, like, and it's not great. I watched few s a few minutes of it and it's not great, but it's like impressive, you know, that like AI can already create these kind of movies. But this is the dial up era of AI, so I think it's only gonna become exponentially more powerful. And that's where you start to get some of these like doomsday scenarios, right? Like If AI goes on this kind of path of like development, like what will that look like? We can't I can't I don't think we can even fathom what it will look like. So the world was vastly transformed by the internet, by social media. We are about to be vastly transformed by AI in ways that we can't even fathom. So what we need to do, I think, as Christians is just like try our best to like double down on wisdom now and like think carefully as carefully as we can now about AI and what we know about AI and the tendencies we're already seeing about AI. For example, the like confusion of like relational categories, that's already problematic. Like the alarm bell should already be going off for Christians when it comes to AI being a supposedly suitable replacement for a romantic partner, a counselor, a life coach, you know It's already problematic that people are looking into AI for that. Alarm bells should be going off about the sycophantic nature of AI. So that this is kind of a well-documented concern about AI. It's sycophantic nature, meaning they are designed, these platforms are designed to be overly friendly, right? To never challenge the user, never tell the user that they're wrong. They only want to flatter the user. They go above and beyond what you ask them to do. This is by design. It goes back to your point about the economics of these tech companies. They're businesses. They want to make money, and the way they make money is they want their platforms to be pleasurable places to live. They want users to spend more and more time on these platforms because it's a pleasant experience. And so, what better way to make a AI pleasant than to literally program it to be sycophantic. To like, you know, when when Brett McCracken asks ChatGPT like, you know, a question, it like responds like with some kind of version of like, you are so wise to ask that question. Like, you are so right. You're you're onto something here. Like, you know, have you noticed that with AI? Like it kind of creepily flattering of you. And like even when you push back on AI, sometimes I'll be pretty harsh back to ChatGPT. I'll be like, I'll call it out. I'll be like, no, like the advice you just gave was flat out wrong. I know for a fact that you just gave me a fact as a fact that wasn't true. And the its response is very like deferential. It's like, yeah, thank you for like saying that. You're so right. You know, you are it so you can see how these technologies are so flattering of us. They make us feel like so in control and so empowered. And that's dangerous, right? Like the we get into trouble as sinful humans when we only surround ourselves with yes men, right? People who only like pat us on the back and tell us we're right. It's good in our lives to have friends, counselors, spouses who actually are. Pretty like willing to call us out when we're wrong and are t truth tellers in our life. We need that for our flourishing. And AI is just not gonna do that for us. So that's really concerning as well, I think.

34:59Why ChatGPT is so sycophantic

37:36Dan Leibrandt

Yeah. Yeah. I use several AI platforms and I found that ChatGPT is the most sycophantic. And pe people said 4o specifically that it was even making people, kill themselves and that that kind of thing. And even just like a funny small example, I was in Iceland about a year ago with a mentor of mine, and we saw this crazy light show. So usually when you see the northern lights, it's just like some kind of like streaks in the s sky. It's nothing too crazy. It's not usually like the pictures, but Occasionally about once a week or so, there'll be about a five minute light show. And it will be like crazy, you know, the lights are all dancing and moving around. And we happened to catch a light show, like the two nights we were there in Iceland. And it was absolutely incredible and mind blowing, like one of the best experiences ever. And soon after, I don't know, maybe five or ten minutes after, I go to ChatGPT and I say, Hey, we just saw this crazy light show. What are the odds that like another one happens tonight? And it was like, it's 50% chance. You, so since you saw it and it was such a crazy light show, you're definitely gonna see another one. And then an hour passes, and I'm like, hey, still haven't seen another light show. Should we keep sitting here? We're like freezing in this car.

37:47Brett McCracken

Right. If I were Yeah. Yeah.

38:50Dan Leibrandt

Well, it's actually probably more like a 30% chance. But yeah, no, you're you probably still have a good chance at catching one tonight. And then we stayed there another hour. I checked back with it's like, well. Yeah, that's more like a ten percent chance. I'm like, okay, so what so we were there three and a half hours and it just totally lied to me because it was trying to tell me what I wanted to hear. So n now from that example, I'm just really skeptical of relying on it for anything.

39:14Brett McCracken

For sure. Yeah. No, it's yeah. And the other dynamic that I think is comical is I'll ask ChatGPT a simple question that I'm really looking for a paragraph max and it'll give me like a thousand words, you know. And can see how that's benefits the platform, right? Like if users actually read all thousand words of the response, that's more minutes that I'm spending on ChatGPT. Whereas if they only gave me the answer in a paragraph, which they probably could do, honestly, and they I would actually prefer if they do that. Then I'm like, I got my answer and then I'm gone. You know, I'm it's less time on the platform. And as you know, time on platform is everything for these tech companies. That's what it's always been about. It's maximizing eyeballs on platforms for as long as possible. So there's more advertising revenue there, there's more addiction potential there. And let's be honest, like getting users to be addicted is the end goal here. You know, these Sam Altman isn't gonna say that. Mark Zuckerberg is never gonna admit that. But that is the goal, right? They engineer these platforms and they hire behavioral psychologists to help engineer these platforms to be maximally addictive, to flatter the user, to kind of engage that dopamine hit part of our brain to keep us to keep us coming back in the way that slot machine addicts keep coming back to the slot machine. So that's what we're up against is the these really rich, powerful companies are pouring a lot of money into tweaking the dials of these technologies to be maximally addictive. So we have to be so careful.

41:17Dan Leibrandt

Yeah. Yeah, it's engineering humans and they there there's no morality or ethics behind it. It really is just optimizing for revenue. And...

41:25Brett McCracken

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It's I mean it's capitalism at its worst, right? Like it like I'm a capitalist and I think like in general, like, you know, revenue is good and profits are good, but when you aren't thinking at all about about the ethics of what you're doing, and that feels like the AI moment that we're in, like it feels like the people leading the charge in these technologies don't really have much of a moral grounding. Like they're brilliant technologists, they're brilliant capitalists, but it's scary when the world is being changed so radically by people who don't necessarily have like a real grasp of solid ethic ethics and morality. Which is why you have this podcast, Dan. And this is why I'm glad you're doing this.

42:14Dan Leibrandt

Yeah. Would you Yeah. Of course. Yeah. Maybe we could just train a model solely on my show and your books and that kind of thing.

42:24Brett McCracken

Well, that would help, I think. Yeah.

42:28What post truth means

42:28Dan Leibrandt

Yeah. Another thing I wanted to bring up, and I feel like you reference this often, is that in twenty sixteen, Oxford Dictionary declared post truth as the international word of the year. Why are you so big on that concept? What does post truth mean to you?

42:49Brett McCracken

Mm. Yeah, I mean, think it speaks to the crisis in epistemology that hasn't it hasn't been new in the digital era, but it's been accelerated by digital technology. I think fifty years ago we were kind of experiencing kind of the death of truth with the of secularization and the marginal marginalizing of religion and kind of the idea of objective truth because there's a god, right? What once you start doing away with God you invariably do away with truth because without without belief in God, you know, what's where do you where do you begin with truth as any sort of meaningful concept? So I think we were already dealing with like a society that had lost its grip on truth. But the internet is a technology that further erodes any sort of stability when it comes to like what can we trust? Because it's inherently a destabilizing force. Like you might see a good argument on one side on Twitter X, and then like five minutes later you see the opposite argument. And you're we constantly have this whiplash of like, which one do I believe? Like which one is more logical? And we're almost to a post-logic moment where it connects to the cognitive atrophy that we're experiencing where we're our brains are so overstimulated that we don't even have the energy to like evaluate arguments anymore. So even even as we're being bombarded with more opinions and kind of takes on truth more than ever before. At the same time, our brains are less equipped to carefully think through these different arguments, right? So what we end up with is just a like a collective like shrug where it's like, I don't know what's true anymore, I don't know what to trust. You kind of you saw with the pandemic five years ago, right? Like the internet was such a dumpster fire during the pandemic because you had like experts arguing one thing and then another said, of experts arguing the exact opposite, right? So, what is the truth about the nature of COVID-19? Like, I don't know. Like, the internet isn't giving any sort of clear consensus, and the experts are not on the same page. So the internet just does that with every issue, right? Like, name your issue, name your debate. You can find good, seemingly logical arguments for every side of every issue. And the collective experience leaves us just like, I'm so discombobulated and so unsure who is right that I'm just gonna I'm just gonna live my life, you do you thing, where you just I'm just gonna follow my gut. That's what we're left to, I think. We're left to just be free agents making our own calls, you know, as we see, as we fe as we see and experience things, it's just kind of like what do we resonate with? Like, that's why the impression, if you're familiar with like digital analytics, impressions have become kind of the king for advertisers, and an impression is just like a split second that like an Eyeball registers an image or an ad. Like so it's precognitive. It's not even like engaging arguments or like ideas. It's just like a vibe, right? I think vibes have become more important than arguments in the digital era because we don't we don't even have the ability to like sort through truth claims anymore. So we're just gonna kinda go with what gives us good vibes or what gives us bad vibes, what gives us the ick, you know?

47:02Brett McCracken

And so if you're an advertiser or even like a Christian apologetic like apologist online you have to think through how how good is your branding? How are you presenting yourself? How are you coming off? Because for a lot of people, especially younger people, that matters more than any argument you're making. Because they can't even like begin to sort through the argument, but like the vibe you give off in the overall aesthetic, that that's what registers with people in the post-truth era. And I'm not saying any of this. Is good. Like I'm not a fan of this development at all. But it is what it is, and it's where we're at. We're in a post-logic, post-truth, post-rationality world. And that's presenting all sorts of new challenges for for everyone, but you know, Christians and apologists and authors, you know, it's my job is to make arguments in articles and books. So what does my job look like in a world where people don't care about arguments anymore and they can't even follow arguments anymore? Like, do I just like put all of my energy into a cool book cover that has a good aesthetic and a good vibe and like kind of go on vibes rather than arguments. I don't know. That's I feel like some people are doing that in today's world. Some authors are best selling authors more more on their vibe. And maybe like their YouTube presence than they are on their actual substance. But they've they've learned that substance doesn't matter as much as it used to. Politicians have learned that, right? Politicians learned that long ago. That it doesn't matter the substance of your platform or your ideas at all, right? It's all about the vibe you project and how that is going to play with the demographics and the audience you're trying to reach. So that's something Postman really hit on back in the 80s, the way that politics has changed to become more about vibes and visual kind of aesthetics than arguments. And we're just seeing that, you know, to the extreme degree right now.

49:21How image took over politics from Lincoln to Trump

49:21Dan Leibrandt

Yeah. I was I was gonna mention Postman that one thing he said is that people would sit through like seven hour debates of you know maybe Abraham Lincoln versus someone else. Yeah.

49:29Brett McCracken

Yeah, the Lincoln-Douglas debates, yeah.

49:32Dan Leibrandt

And also if a politician, maybe someone like an Abraham Lincoln, was walking down the street, most people wouldn't even recognize him because people just knew you strictly off of your speech and writing. And like what is your reasoning ability? How actually smart are you? What are your arguments? And you're saying now, Donald Trump is the epitome of this, that he's like this big billionaire, been on these TV shows. No, it's politics aside, but of just his persona and his archetype of being most famous out there. And it's funny because yeah, I think you were mentioning too that Neil Postman reflected on that like Reagan being an actor was a big deal. And now Trump is...

49:44Brett McCracken

Your words. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah, I know.

50:18Dan Leibrandt

The ultimate anti politician.

50:20Brett McCracken

I know Postman was so horrified by the fact that a TV actor like Reagan could become president, but that feels so quaint, you know, forty years later when we have, you know, Trump and now it's like normal, like reality TV stars becoming like influential politicians is like super normal. You know, there's like there's like five people in Trump's cabinet who were like former reality TV stars. It's just that it's that normal now. And I'm not saying that, it's not possible. You know, you can be an actor and a reality TV star and be a good politician, but it just shows what's changed is image and kind of media saturation and your ability to perform, you know, on camera is a big part of political success in the way, in a way that it wasn't in the 19th century when, you know, Lincoln and his oratory skills and debates. Mattered more than his overall kind of brand or like vibe.

51:23Dan Leibrandt

Hmm, yeah. So would you say for people that are good political figures or commentators that you just need a good mix of both? Or almost Trojan horse with the good brand?

51:37Brett McCracken

Say so say that again. Let me make sure I'm understanding your question there.

51:41Dan Leibrandt

Yeah. So people nowadays who maybe are good figures in the Christian space, whatever, what is like the right balance or what would you recommend to them regarding like the branding and vibes versus the actual like material and logic?

51:52Brett McCracken

Hm, yeah. Yeah, that's a okay, yeah. It is a good question because it there's a degree of realism. Like if you if you have a good argument to make and you believe that it's important for peop for audiences to hear your argument, you just have to understand that like your your aesthetic, your visual representation of yourself on social media, on you know, the design of your book or whatever, like your overall branding matters, like especially for younger potential readers. So I think it is a both hand of like don't downplay the importance of like a really solid substantive argument. Don't coddle the audience or like dumb down your your arguments, but try to meet them in a way that's gonna be appealing and you know attractive on that vibe level, I guess. So don't don't throw all throw out the substance and go all in on vibes, but don't neglect them either, I guess, is what I'm saying.

53:09Christian hope in the age of AI

53:09Dan Leibrandt

Yeah, totally agree. Now I don't know, some people might be feeling pessimistic after listening to this show of it's social media is ruining ruining us, AI is ruining us. So what is the hopeful future and what actions can we take to ensure that, we don't get AI psychosis, we're not addicted to our phones and all this bad stuff.

53:30Brett McCracken

And yeah, I think the hope is really just the eschatological reality that we know as Christians, which is that we know the end of the story, right? Like God God is triumphant, that n the gates of hell will not you know, prevail against the church. So the church will not be defeated. We will the church has always gone through eras of intense technological and cultural change and it's been disruptive, it's posed new challenges for the church, for Christians, but the church endures, right? God and the Holy Spirit preserves the church. And I think that I get a lot of hope knowing that. And that's why I write for The Gospel Coalition. That's why I'm writing these books for the church, because I want to be part of maybe how God helps preserve the church through this period of great transition. Like I wanna be a resource to church leaders and Christians to be light In what could be a really dark new period of culture. It's very possible that AI brings some sort of utopian aspects to civilization, but also brings in like a real dark ages, you know, in a in certain ways. I think what happens in every dark age in history is the church endures, right? And the church is a light. We preserve ancient wisdom in the midst of eras of foolishness. So I get hope with that and yeah ultimately I think there's one way to look at this moment for Christians is we can really be s a source of life and wisdom at a time when a lot of people are gonna be really Disoriented, and a lot of people are going to be asking big questions in the age of AI, like what does it mean to be human? What how am I actually different as a human from this AI robot who walks and talks and functions very much like a human? Like we have good answers for that. Christians are well positioned to come alongside people asking those questions and offer a compelling framework for anthropology and what it means to be human. You know, other people are gonna be asking, like, what's the point of life? If AI takes away jobs and you know, if the if what some people are saying is gonna happen happens and none of us are working really in 20 years and we're on universal basic basic income and we're just kind of like having permanent leisure time b in the robots are working, like a lot of people are gonna be having major existential crisis moments. Like what is the point of life? Like what am I here for? Right? Am I here to just watch Netflix all day, like some character in Brave New World? You know, Aldous Huxley's book. I'm just plugged into this media machine and just like the Matrix, right? Like, is that what I'm here for? Just to be like dead and numb and consuming all the time? I'm not saying that this is gonna be the world AI creates, but it's one potential future that people are talking about. In any case, there's gonna be lots of questions about the purpose of life, and Christians are well equipped to offer an answer to that. You know, God has a mission, He has a plan for us, and I think people are gonna be really hungry for that. So my hope in this moment is that Christians can rise to the occasion to not to not be the most anxious in the world, but to be the ones who would have the most clarity and the most kind of hopeful answers to give at a time of great fear and uncertainty.

57:35The Wisdom of Sleep and where to find Brett

57:35Dan Leibrandt

Amen. That was great. Brett, this has been such a great show with you. We'll wrap it up here. Where can people find you online and connect with you?

57:44Brett McCracken

You can go to brettmccracken.com, which is like my author's website. You're gonna learn about all my books there. I also write for The Gospel Coalition, usually on a weekly basis, so most of my new writing is found there, thegospelcoalition.org. Other than that, my books are all on Amazon. You can find them print, digital, audiobook, whatever format you prefer.

58:12Dan Leibrandt

Awesome. Yeah. So everyone go make sure to order Brett's books and read them. I was reading Scrolling Ourselves to Death and The Wisdom Pyramid. Awesome books. I'll read the new one as well. Tell us a little bit about the new book.

58:25Brett McCracken

Yeah, The Wisdom of Sleep, it's actually kind of more about this topic that we've been talking about than you would think. Because my take is basically, you know, sleep is something humans always have done and always will do, but we're sleeping less and we're struggling with sleep more in today's technological era than than ever before. And why is that? What even though we ha we have all these creature comforts, you know, climate controlled houses, like sleep aid, sleep medicine. Our sleep is bad. Like the World Health Organization described it as a global sleep epidemic a couple of years ago. So I kind of tie together like a technological critique of our optimization obsession and this world where humans are starting to think of themselves more and more like machines. So I'm using this topic of sleep to really make a case for humanity and what it means to be a limited embodied human in an age of machines where we are tempted to limitlessness and kind of like godlike omnipotence through technology. Sleep teaches us the opposite, right? It the wisdom of sleep is that we are not limitless and we are limited creatures who have to be flat out on our backs for a third of our lives. And that's a good thing. It's a good thing for us. Mm-hmm...

59:52Dan Leibrandt

Yeah. It's humbling. And I'm sure these tech people are gonna try to figure out a way where we can never sleep and no women get pregnant and you can just create babies in labs. So I'm right there with you on all of this. I we are super aligned on our kind of theology or philosophy here.

1:00:02Brett McCracken

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. The thing that these tech folks need to hear is that limits are not obstacles to be overcome. They are gifts that are for our flourishing, right? Limits are for our good. And that's kind of a central idea in Christian theology. And our secular technology world is trying to push against that.

1:00:30Dan Leibrandt

Totally agree. So yeah, everyone go buy Brett's books and also where can they find you on social media?

1:00:37Brett McCracken

Yeah, Instagram is probably the one I'm most active on these days. You can find I think it's bwmccracken on Instagram. LinkedIn, I also enjoy that. I kind of enjoy certain social media platforms more than others. X, I'm not on all that much, but I'm on there as well. So you can find me wherever you prefer.

1:00:59Dan Leibrandt

Awesome. So all those links will be in the description. And Brett, thanks so much again for coming on. This has been awesome.

1:01:04Brett McCracken

Yeah, thank you, Dan. Great conversation.

1:01:06Dan Leibrandt

Course.