Episode Summary
The summary and key moments are written by AI from the episode transcript.
Paul VanderKlay is the pastor of Living Stones Christian Reformed Church in Sacramento and has made YouTube videos since 2017, when he began commenting on Jordan Peterson’s Bible lectures. Dan asks him what Peterson got wrong. VanderKlay says joining The Daily Wire boxed Peterson into a political silo, and that while Peterson was right that people can’t live without meaning, he never took the step many of his listeners took into church. Peterson’s wife and daughter went in, VanderKlay says, and it’s better on the inside.
He argues that ritual is the foundation of a civilization, because people turn an overwhelming world into small shared patterns, which churches curate and pass on. He traces the rise of Orthodoxy through the seeker movement, the emerging church and the Young, Restless, Reformed, and says people exhausted by choice are drawn to a tradition that asks them to submit. When Dan reads from VanderKlay’s Substack about chatbots competing with the church, he says the algorithm doesn’t care and the church’s job is to turn people who receive love into people who give it. He calls AI clearly spiritual but says almost everything in this world has a demonic element, pointing to C.S. Lewis’s The Screwtape Letters.
They also talk about sports as a religion and why we don’t wrestle against flesh and blood. VanderKlay explains Estuary’s protocol of person, pitch, point and play and why in-person community goes deeper than anything online, and closes by inviting listeners to look for an Estuary group.
Key Moments
- 01:25Why VanderKlay thinks joining The Daily Wire boxed Peterson into a political silo
- 14:08Why ritual is the foundation of a civilization, from the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier to the seventh-inning stretch
- 24:37Why so many people are converting to Orthodoxy, starting with exhaustion from too much choice
- 35:24How the church should respond to chatbots that are always affirming
- 41:04Whether AI is demonic, and why he calls it clearly spiritual
- 54:59Estuary's conversation protocol of person, pitch, point and play
Read the full transcriptHide the transcript
Full Transcript
00:00What Jordan Peterson got wrong
Paul VanderKlay, welcome to the Dan Leibrandt Show.
Good to be here.
So, Paul, you became known for commenting on Jordan Peterson's Bible lectures about nine years ago. And now nine years later, I wanted to ask you, what do you think Jordan Peterson got wrong?
Hmm Well when I saw how people were being energized by his biblical lectures. I knew that it's really difficult to have a relationship with a guy on a stage with a million other YouTube subscribers. And so I knew that there would be a need for much more pastoral conversation, sort of low to the ground, and probably something where people could find one another. And I didn't know how to go about building that or doing that. But I was interested in the phenomena and I thought it was important and I couldn't really find colleagues to discuss it with in my own professional circles. And since it was going on on YouTube, I thought I'll make a YouTube video. And then one thing led to another, and people did want to talk about it, and people did want to get together to talk about it, and so the thing is just sort of grew from there. So his focus he's got Peterson Academy, that came out of it. Obviously he's been ill for a while now, and so he's not you know, not doing his own podcast or some of the things that he was doing. I think going to Daily Wire was a mistake. I think that segmented him politically, and then he just sort of before twenty nineteen, and really especially before twenty eighteen, his his appeal was much more broad. And then after twenty nineteen and Daily Wire, he very much sort of got shoehorned into a political silo. And I thought that was that was lamentable because I thought lots of people beyond the political spectrum could benefit from what he was doing and by virtue of the culture war they just weren't accessible to him. So...
02:18Why Jordan Peterson won't say he believes in Christ
Hmm. I've seen on some of these different videos, but maybe I think it was a 20v1 video, if you've seen this, where it was and actually it was him supposed to be as a Christian against 20 others who are, I guess, atheist or non-Christian. And someone asked him, you know, do you believe in Christ? And then he goes down this path of like, well, what do you mean to believe? So why does someone like Peterson struggle so much with saying that he believes in Christ?
Well, he that answer has been remarkably stable throughout his YouTube sojourn. And it has to do with the fact that he understands that belief is not as simple as we imagine it to be. And every preacher would know that because a lot of sermons devolve into you say you believe this, but you don't do it. And Jesus preached many sermons like that too. And so belief is not as simple a thing as people would like to think. Yet, for many people, they experience it sort of as one thing. And so after a while, his wanting to sort of parse that carefully, people got tired of hearing it and they just sort of wanted him to. Pick a side. And I think a better question might have been, you know, will you submit to a tradition or to a community or to let's say a spiritual master like Christ? And because obviously for a cognitive psych for he's not a cognitive s scientist, but for a psychologist like himself. Th these are complex terms and he gets very professorial and wants to lecture about the complex terms.
Hmm. But for someone like that, because I know several smart people in my life like that, that are huh, it does make sense. And obviously you can't deny that Jesus existed and that this something really big happened 2,000 years ago. But is there a way to help these kind of intellectual types make that jump, make that leap of faith?
Everybody's strengths and their weaknesses are deeply intertwined. There are many, many very smart people that easily submit to Christ and become part of his church and live fruitful Christian lives. Jordan is Jordan. He's idiosyncratic. I think you know, I think it would have blessed him to do it, but for some reason he hasn't, didn't. His wife has become a Roman Catholic. His daughter, to the best of my knowledge, worships at an evangelical church. You know, I it's a little surprising, but that's Jordan and you know, it's his it's his to do.
05:29Is the meaning crisis getting better or worse
Yeah. So back to the you commenting and making videos on Jordan's Bible series, that at least was largely around the movement of the meaning crisis and that s especially so many young men were just finding a lack of meaning in their lives. And I wanted to ask you, especially because you have so much context around this, you have your online communities, you have Estuary. You have your your church itself. Have you found that the meaning crisis has gotten better or worse?
I think so it was John Vervaeke who really coined and popularized that term. He was a colleague of Jordan's at University of Toronto. I found John fairly early on, and John's had his own career on the internet and has the Vervaeke Foundation. I think when John started, he began with the assumption that the legacy religions, as he called them, were were unavailable and not useful to people. And I think he would change that. And I think he has. He the legacy religions, as he calls them, have been a space where a lot of refugees from the meaning crisis have gone for comfort and shelter. I early on, I just started talking to people as a pastor, and it was very clear that there was a lot of depression. And a lot of it seemed to be induced by a low-level nihilism. And I think that's really sort of the bottom of kind of a reductionist materialism that with the new atheism sort of became this atheist agnostic bottom where people began to look around and say nothing matters. And what Peterson was right about is that you cannot live without meaning. If you have meaning, lots of people got there you know, noticed that, you know, especially during the Second World War and the Holocaust. A lot of a lot of people noticed that, that, you know, can survive almost anything with meaning. Nietzsche noticed it, others did. So Peterson was sort of following in that tradition. Now, John sort of assumed that he thought the legacy religions wouldn't provide meaning and what I think we've seen is that Christianity has in fact done that. And we're watching people get more religious and not less. And even the secular research like Clay Routledge has done just verifies that. When people stop believing in God, they start believing in astrology, witchcraft, you know, just sort of a vague purposism in the universe. Things happen for a reason. Things like this. People can't live without meaning. And if they don't have meaning, they die. That's just a fact about human beings and religions have long curated, channeled, given a container for people to pursue meaning communally and with some direction.
09:00Can sports give your life meaning
Hmm. Now, I'm not Catholic, but I do like to listen to Bishop Barron. I think he's great and very smart and theologically wise. And something that he said that really stuck out to me, and I'd like to see if you agree, is that the further you go outside of yourself, the more meaning you have. So maybe even if you're on a football team, you feel more meaning because it's something bigger than yourself. You're working with teammates, it's not about you. So would you say that's the goal? Like to get as far outside of yourself as possible?
It's not the goal, but you need it. Breathing isn't the goal, but you need it. So, and I think, you know, for that reason, sports as well is one of the most popular sort of religious thing that people have. And, you know, sports for for youth and young people is a very helpful thing. It gets them into a community. Now, the difficulty with sports is that it can only go so high. Getting a ball over a line or through a through a circle. That's great. It's great. You learn team you learn a whole bunch of things. But once you start asking bigger questions that are much more existential, sports isn't going to get you above that. So it's a good it's a good booster rocket to help people survive this solipsist solipsistic nihilism that's been around a long time. But yeah, no Barron is right.
I agree sports isn't enough, but I see that happen with a lot of people that maybe they make their whole personality and all of their meaning around just cheering on a sports team and they take it super seriously and they get actually depressed when the team loses. So I think sports in a way can be its own religion.
Yeah, I absolutely. And it's an extremely popular one. It just I mean it's sort of like it's a food, but it's not a superfood. It's kind of it's kind of chicken wings. I mean it's it'll it'll sustain you and it sustains a lot of people and some people that becomes their whole thing. Yet for all the sports fans, if you walk through a cemetery only a very few headstones will make reference to their favorite team.
Hmm, that's good. So I guess that's part of the way to qualify meaning or what really matters. It's like...
We find meaning all over the place. And part of what's important about meaning is it's essential for survival. Just surviving is deeply meaningful. And in that sense, the security and affluence that we've created for each other in parts of the world like the United States that provokes other deeper question. And the path that a lot of people have taken, I just spoke this week or last week to a guy named Nick Acker, who was raised in a secular family. And as many people have done, and this is sort of also downstream from Peterson, because a lot of people sort of gathered around Peterson in this way. They looked around and said, you know, what has sustained viable and high-functioning cultures have been religious institutions. And so whether or not you believe In the metaphysical claims of those religious institutions, it's quite clear those religious institutions are fulfilling an important function. I think a fair number of the founding fathers, like Benjamin Franklin and George Washington, had that approach. And so while they were supportive of religious communities and would participate in them on and off, they recognized that just from an observable way, these institutions were vital for the health of a civilization and so supported them, even if they didn't believe the metaphysical claims. Difficulty is once you get into those institutions, then suddenly you're going to be asking deeper questions about, well, are we just eating bread and drinking juice here? Is that what this is about? Is the world so arbitrary that almost any ritual will do? And then you get into really a lot of what Peterson was pulling at was that, no, these rituals are likely connected to deeper things. And where where Peterson, I think, failed to go was to recognize that he as an individual needed to participate in them for his own sake. And yeah. And but a lot of people went to the edge of what Peterson was teaching and then took the next step into church.
14:01Why humans need ritual
Mm. Can you expand on that more of like why ritual is important and actually getting involved?
I was watching the movie The Northman, a few days ago. I hadn't seen it yet. And I was watching at the beginning of the movie the Viking chieftain was walking through town and I was just thinking about all of the participation that went into the fact that one person in the town got his pick of the women, got his share of the spoils, could order someone being killed. If you just look at how human beings organize themselves in groups, that's we sort of can jump to a level and say, well, there's sort of a narrative around that, but it's often not presented as a narrative that's sort of too big. What there are are all of these rituals. And we can't help but ritualize almost everything. This gets into a lot of cognitive science that John Vervaeke has taught and explored because the world is just too large. And there are too many choices one has to make. And so if you observe yourself closely, what you'll discover is that you very quickly create rituals for yourselves. Now you might not call them rituals, you might call them habits or patterns. Or things like that, but you'll put on your clothes a certain way. You'll eat a certain way. You'll and then you'll begin to discover that the certain ways that you're putting on your clothes and eating and going to work and going about your work, these are rituals that you've picked up from other people because we collectively and community have been taking them and testing them and instilling them. And all of this sort of gets built up into. A civilizational framework that is for the most part implicit, that are all these little microprograms that we follow. And these microprograms are basically rituals.
And these rituals are deeply, deeply important to us. And they dig into us deeply. For example, someone raises a flag and salutes. You go to the tomb of the unknown soldier in Washington, DC, and the Marine Guard are just practicing pure ritual. And in that sense, the individual disappears and a higher collective emerges. And we find those collectives deeply meaningful and extraordinarily powerful for creating arenas and contexts where we feel secure, where we participate, where there's meaning. And in fact, you find this at sporting events the seven in the seventh inning stretch, singing, take me out to the ball game. And you find it with you find it with pitchers, you find it with free throw shooters. Human beings have to take an overly complex world, distill into much smaller little patterns, and then we watch each other do those patterns, and then somehow we know we are on the same page. Now we know what's coming next, because you want to really disturb a person. Throw them into a context where they don't know what's happening next, and people get very upset very quickly. And so ritual is the foundation of a civilization. And what churches and religious institutions do is curate and propagate those rituals and in that way sustain a civilization.
Ha ha. Hmm, that was so good. That that was a really compelling argument that humans are ri ritualistic. And basically what you're saying at the end there is that like if we are ritualistic, then maybe as maybe Pageau would say, there's like a hierarchy of rituals and you need to chase the highest of the rituals.
And we're constantly evaluating rituals. If I so there's a fair number of homeless people around, they have their little rituals, and you watch them do their rituals. And some of their rituals are self-destructive. Others of their rituals aren't. And so we're always evaluating these rituals, looking for rituals that will sort of get us more, more of what we want. So my most bare bones definition of religion is that which is highest and how to get there. And so the highest thing might be for your favorite team to win the Super Bowl. But then, you have Tom Brady going and winning the Super Bowl how many times and asking, Is this all there is? 'Cause and what, Jordan Peterson again did a ton of work on this stuff. Talked about the fact that what we actually hate is losing. And what we what we most enjoy is just right before we win. And so that's what makes the Super Bowl game so exciting because you're just peaking there. But once you win, it's like and one of my favorite illustrations of this is the movie The Truman Show, where you know everybody's what's gonna happen to Truman and everybody's watching and everybody's watching, and then he gets up and he says goodbye and he goes through the door and then they show all the watchers. And very quickly they pick up the remote and what's on next? Because it's that endpoint that we're always looking for.
Sex, yeah. Hmm, that's so good. And that's a really good example from the Truman Show. I actually I forgot about that, but yeah, I've seen the movie twice or three times and that that really resonates. And yeah, no, I've come to understand that's how dopamine works, that it's the guess like the chemical of chasing, that it's never enough. Seems like that's almost like the epitome of America, that nothing is ever enough. You never have enough money, you never have enough cars. Never have a big enough house. That has to be damaging, right?
Yeah. And again, what happens to people when they hit that enough times they begin to ask much higher questions. And that's part of the reason why these legacy religions aren't going anywhere, because these legacy religions have been working on those problems for thousands of years. And it's not, you know, and they've learned some things. But as with many things, there's always an inside and an outside to something. And people have an experiential and an instinctive impulse to know that I suspect inside is better. It's fun watching your favorite team win the World Series or the Super Bowl or the championship, but just you know. It's more fun to be on the team and to win it. And what religion allows many people to get into is the inside. And again, so Jordan, Jordan's been watching all of this from the outside. His wife went in, his daughter went in, and it's like, Jordan, go in. It's better on the inside. Now there are there are trade-offs. Going into the inside. Because if you stand on the outside, it's like, well, I'm still then a consumer. Once you go in, now suddenly you're committed. And you're going to, it's like getting married. You know, I forsake all others. Well, what if I married this one? What if I married this one? Well, you can you can date forever. But if you're just having children while you're dating, that's not going to go well. And so it's often the case that. People will see married men with children and an intact family who have maybe only slept with one woman their whole life, and men who have slept with thirty, forty, fifty women will look at the married person with a family and say, I'd give anything to have what you had. Well, you only get that by going inside and again, that's what religions do. They say you need to come in, which means all these other consumer alternatives you're going to forsake and you're gonna commit to this path and you're gonna go. And that's something that we as Americans we're a little we like we like being consumers. We like having options. And marriage, joining a church. Doing all many of these things involves committing.
Hmm, yes. It's all about freedom and optionality and do whatever you want. But actually then you become a slave to your freedom in some weird way, where it's you would actually be like you're saying, much better off if you just committed to the things that actually matter instead of saying, Well, but I'm so free to do whatever I want. It's like you don't even really want to do those things, as as Paul says.
And if you're going to have different journeys inside a commitment. And they may not all be pleasant, but that's what life is. And so you embrace the sufferings that every journey entails and you take the risks. But...
24:00Why so many people are converting to Orthodoxy
Something you've hinted at several times, and we talked about briefly before the show was this b big move to Orthodoxy. That yeah, I'm based in Chicago. I see a lot of people becoming Catholic. So it's kind of two sides of the same coin. But just more generally speaking, a lot of people are moving to Orthodoxy. And some of my favorite Christian thinkers are Orthodox. And maybe they were previously atheist or Calvinist or whatever, and now they're Orthodox. What how do you explain this? Why are so many people moving towards Orthodoxy specifically?
Well, I think people are exhausted by choice and Orthodoxy is a tradition where you promise to submit, submit to your priest. Your priest is supposed to be submitted to the bishop. The bishop is supposed to be submitted to the patriarch. You know, in Catholicism, similar thing. So that's very attractive. Many other traditions have that too. I think Orthodoxy Orthodoxy lines up okay, this gets into some stuff. America has long been a predominantly Protestant cult culture, and even Catholicism in America has needed to imbibe and assume a ton of Protestant code. So, but these have sort of been mapped territory on the American scene. The big Protestant religious movement of the 80s and 90s, you had sort of the Jesus movement in the 60s and 70s, which brought Calvary Chapel, contemporary Christian music, all of this stuff. 80s and 90s, you had the Seeker movement, which was Willow Creek, Saddleback, using business models, management by objective to sort of strengthen the church and help it be more intelligible to usually the refugees of the mainline movements that were deteriorating. That was followed up, and that that was dom predominantly a boomer movement in evangelicalism, was followed up by the emerging church movement, which was sort of a fracturing of all of this because sort of culturally everyone was dealing with postmodernity. And the emerging church movement was this massive fragmentation of the church and some people were became politics became their church, new atheism came to the fore, Young, Restless and Reformed Calvinism became very hot in the nineties and aughts. And yet all of this sort of everything was sort of falling apart. I see Jordan Peterson, Jonathan Pageau very much in sort of trying to get beyond postmodernism. And what Peterson saw in terms of perennial myths and structures and rhythms and routines, Pageau applied in Orthodoxy and talked about it in symbolism. And that gave people a path into something that satisfied a lot of the different elements of the emerging church movement that people optioned. So if you were wanted to be wanted to have religion or wanted to have politics as your religion. Maybe it meant went mainline or maybe you just were very political. If you went conservative, you know, a lot of those people went Young, Restless, and Reformed where they were committed, and they were committed to the Bible as understood sort of in a reformational way. They're sort of neo-Puritans. Orthodoxy is an interesting example because on one hand, it satisfies a lot of the elements of the emerging church movement without necessarily having to integrate them fully or choose between them. Because on one hand, it's a tradition that purports to be monolithic. It's just Orthodoxy. Now, if you look very close, you'll discover that well, they're about as fragmented as Protestants.
It's also ancient. But if you look closely, they're having to, they're really spreading on the internet. And so a lot there's a lot of things about it that, well, do you have to be politically conservative and be Orthodox? You can find very politically conservative people in Orthodoxy. And really, when I look at certain Orthodox groups, they are just sort of the continuing, they're the continuing continuation of, let's say, the Young, Restless and Reformed movement. They're very confessionalistic, they're very dogmatic, they're very hard and stern and demanding and authoritarian. Then you look at others in the Orthodox Church and they're almost hippie-ish. You know you do you come into the Orthodox Church and experience the beauty. And you can create your own journey through this. And well you can find the you can find the priest in Austin, Texas, who bought McMansion and is on YouTube and is all about lifting weights and you know the gym bros and the Ortho bros are sort of one thing. And then you can find another church in Austin, Texas where it's very open, it's very beauty centered. They're not dogmatic. You can find you can find one of the priests giving a very you know, talking about universalism and the other priest who loves him dearly and is part of the same parish, saying, No, I don't believe in universalism. And they're all right there, this diverse, this diverse congregation, all within Orthodoxy. And so part of the benefit is also that and a woman who who I know now, she was in Rebel Wisdom, which was sort of a key YouTube channel in this. And they had these campfire things, and she basically asked very sincerely but innocently, you know, maybe Orthodoxy doesn't have all of the baggage that Catholicism and Protestantism has in terms of, you know, relating to church and politics. And it's like once you start, you know, part of that is just because of the iron curtain. Once you start reading the history of the Church of the East, it's like Catholicism.
Another civilizational religion. It's just that it was eaten by Islam and communism. And so, but it's new in America. And so that's you know, that's a whole new thing. But it's sort of like once you connect those wires, things are gonna be going both ways on those wires. So it's gonna be very interesting. I mean, I celebrate the Orthodox moment. Many of the people that I've grown to love in my personal relationships on the internet have gone Orthodox and have been deeply blessed by that. And I cheer that. I cheer them on and I want them to submit to their priest and go to confession and go to liturgy and I want them to do it. But whether or not this how big this is going to get in America, that's a very open question. Because, if you look at the actual numbers of Orthodox in America, they're still overall, you've got some parishes that are growing, usually from this movement, and you've got a lot of immigrant parishes that are declining, Catholic or other immigrant groups. So it's a very dynamic situation.
Hmm. Yeah. I was gonna mention a point you brought up too is that I think part of it's just the novelty that humans naturally crave novelty. And it's weird because it's you have kind of the both sides of like super old religion, but also like in the US, like very at least previously, maybe even just fifty years ago, there were very few Orthodox. Like it's kind of the standard to either be Protestant or, you know, in Chicago there's a ton of Catholics. So I for me growing up, I saw that if you become Christian, you become Catholic. But I could there's part of me with this new Orthodox movement where I'm like, hmm, maybe, maybe I'll try out an Orthodox church. Maybe I'll give it a chance because it's just something new. And if humans have this sh shiny object syndrome, we're like, something new. I'll I guess I'll try it.
And it's very different. Yeah, and there's a ton of wonderful stuff in Orthodoxy to learn. They've got thousands of years of tradition and church fathers and I mean it's a it's a very viable, mature system. And so, you know, I yeah, I can see why I there there's a whole lot of reasons why it works for people now. And many of my friends who are Orthodox, Nathan Jacobs, I think is very good on this. It just really fits in to usually where a lot of people who refugees from the meaning crisis, especially from postmodernity, Orthodoxy fits really nicely. Part of that because a lot of these ideas, postmodernity, ideas within postmodernity, they've been around for a very long time. And so there are very old answers to some of these questions. And you can go out and find them and recontextualize them. So It's good.
34:03AI chatbots vs the church
Yeah. Yeah. So we talked about the religion of sports and also the influx of Orthodoxy. And another kind of new religion that I wanted to mention is, I guess you could say the religion of AI, that more and more people are kind of worshiping their chatbot. Especially you see this within the bigger tech companies like Anthropic, where you hear stories of, people that are actually worshiping it and saying it's God or that they're building God, that kind of thing. And I wanted to mention a quote from your Substack earlier this year. It was January 14th. I believe it was, Will this be the end? Or under the this quote was under the heading, Will this mean the end of the church age? And you wrote, The church is facing a sort of competition like it never has before. Your local pastor's sermon is in competition with the best preaching your congregates can get or can find on YouTube. The precious few moments of love and attention given by a busy small church pastor is evil easily outstripped by the non-judgmental, ever-affirming, always present voice of the chatbot. What do churches do about this? And you as a pastor, how do you defend against this?
It's hard to know. It's hard to know where this thing goes. So on one hand, the chatbots can be, very sycophantic and very affirming. How long will that play for a person? I don't know. How long will it continue to be free? I don't know. There's just a lot we don't know. So we'll see it play out. The church has to continue to do what the church does, which is figure out how to love people and how to form Christ in them to help them become lovers of other people. The real turn it everyone wants to be loved. But to love others, especially hard to love people, well that's a very demanding path. And the job of the church is to turn people from people who receive love. To people who can give love. And so we'll see. We'll see. It's hard to know. I mean AI has continued to change dramatically, you know, every few months, if you pay much attention to the chatbots. And as you get to know them better, you begin to see you begin to see their bottoms. And if in fact the enshittification of the internet. Right now as they're burning through the venture capital, there's lots of free. And maybe it's gonna get to like YouTube. I mean YouTube is great. You can feed it all the you know, all the video you want and they'll host it for free. Yeah, but then they're gonna put ad, ad, ad, ad, ad, ad. Whether or not you're monetized, no matter how many ads you put in, you two it's their platform. And the path of the internet has been pretty clear. So will AI just get, shittified so badly because they've got to make up for all this, they've got to get their return on all their venture capital? I don't know. So it's 'cause if it's funny because if you look at the internet, and we've seen the same the same issue. Same with smartphones. If you spend time with people who let's say the free smartphones are better than they've ever been. But human beings also have a tremendous capacity for boredom. When we see that repetition enough, we get bored, even if it's a good thing. You can only eat so much candy and then you're looking for something else. So a certain level of human being, certain groups of people are probably gonna get sucked in, similar to what you see with, let's say, addiction. And then the church isn't going anywhere. Just like AA isn't going out of business. And they'll be there'll be chat group anonymous, twelve steps that form. And it's those twelve step groups are almost always feeders into Christian churches. Happens all the time.
Yeah, I agree. And I think part of the point of that article or one point you made was that, hey, look, maybe we can take this as inspiration, be better as humans. Like something I've thought about, I've talked to my mom about actually, because she's a therapist and she owns a therapy practice. And it kind of reveals to us the this concept my mentor has taught me of like active listening that when you're talking with someone, really let them talk and ask more about what they're talking about and really show that you care. And to the AI's point or to the AI's advantage, it's really good at pretending to care, to pretend to listen. Someone will, you know, voice out all their concerns, all their problems, and the AI AI will acknowledge every single one and reply in like two pages and like, wow, you are so right on this. And no, you're you're not a bad person. It's like I think we need to be better listeners and communicators.
Yep, no argument there. And but of course it's about caring. The algorithm doesn't care. It really doesn't. It just sort of fools us into having an experience of caring. And you know, we human beings do that too. Corporations have long done that. You know. The you know here, you know, Apple, isn't it Apple Care? Isn't isn't that the name of their support? It's Apple Care. Apple cares about you. All right. And we've gotten pretty cynical about that. And so, I think that cynicism is gonna find its place with the AI as well.
40:31Is AI demonic
Hmm. Yeah, some people I honestly can't believe this. When you really start to reason through what's going on, like whether the AI is conscious or not. I think it's clearly no, at least in terms of like, obviously it's a machine, but some of the people that I've listened to think there is something spiritual going on here that maybe either the people creating the machines or the output of the machines themselves is some kind of manifestation of demons or the devil himself. Do you see any credibility there?
I think it's clearly spiritual. The difficulty is the pictures we bring to that worldview. And it and it's not dissimilar to the question of consciousness. It's not Yeah, now I'm gonna sound like Jordan Peterson about believe. It's not entirely clear what on earth we're talking about. Now I know when my dog is conscious and when he's not. I sort of know when I'm conscious and when I'm not, but I can't really know. If you're conscious or that my dog is conscious. It's a question similar to the whole question of is green the same for you as it is for me? And that gets into the whole inside outside thing. The fact that AI has a demonic element to it. Well, absolutely, but almost everything in this world does. The question is, what are we talking about? And I think part of how that that term has come to be used is it's just sort of a like a negative a dramatic negative flag that we hang on things. Is sports demonic? Well, in some ways, yeah.
But if you'd say the NFL is demonic, people would be like, Well, how is the NFL demonic? It's not like a Ouija board or a or something you see in, you know, a Hollywood movie about demons. No, it's nothing like that. But what on earth do we mean by that word? So, and if you read something like C.S. Lewis's Screwtape Letters, one of the things that one of the demons says to the other is, if you really want to feast on a human soul, just keep them occupied with mindless things on and on and on. And so maybe Candy Crush is demonic. And you say, Well, what's what's demonic about Candy Crush? Well, you're frittering or Sudoku, you're frittering your life away in some little frame. Is that demonic? Well, what on earth do we mean by the word? So that's the question. And again, you're if you're if you're gonna want to make progress on a question like that, I don't know where you can more safely go to look for conversation partners and a tradition to be helpful than the church. And so there again, you're just sort of stuck saying, hmm, where can I go to help figure this out?
Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, as I've thought about all these questions regarding AI in the future, I just keep coming back to the Bible and the church. I'm like, well, there's an answer, then there's a good answer for all these things, which is a indication that it's true. Regarding stuff being demonic, that was a great example from CS Lewis. Is there a way to know? You know, for people listening, is there a way for them to know if something is demonic or not?
So usually when people talk about something demonic, I have a hierarchy of these things. They're they're usually looking at, let's say, critters. So there's a lot of fascination now with extraterrestrials. And if you read Rod Dreher or some others, you go to Skinwalker Ranch and maybe you'll get to see a demon. There you go. And sometimes people are, you know, demon-possessed and you will call an exorcist. Sometimes people have demons, but those are and those are the critter level. Those are fairly low level things. Middle spirits, the kinds of things that we see moving yesterday's election around. Those are sort of those are spirits that possess people in groups. And those are spirits that possess whole nations. Now, when people say demonic, they're usually thinking the critter level. They're not thinking that level. But it's quite clear to me at least that when Paul is talking about principalities and powers in the New Testament, he's talking about the kinds of things that are animating the Roman Empire. But when we see demon possession, we see someone who, maybe has. Knowledge that they couldn't ordinarily have or superhuman strength or is somehow just sort of disabled by a local critter level spirit, whereas these far larger spirits are drawing us into world wars and separating families. You know, it's one thing to have a to have a demon that is making a person non functional. What level demon makes a family not functional? What level demon makes a nation or a civilization non functional? And we don't usually use that word for those things, but those things are far more consequential.
46:50Has Paul seen demonic possession
Hmm. If you don't mind me asking, ha have you seen something like demonic possession?
No, I'm gonna gonna sound like Jordan Peterson. Define C.
Ha ha...
So it's I on one hand I see it all around us. I see it on a person that can't have a conversation even with a family member because a politician gets named or a group gets named and then they just start running this program. And everyone in this group or in this cluster is dehumanized by that program. I'm seeing a demon when I see that. Now, what we're tend to be fascinated by are the kinds of stories where, someone is tremendously disabled by something that, even trained exorcists have to do a fair amount of work to disambiguate from mental health issues, if in fact that can be disambiguated. And figure out what exact what treatment does this person need. And so traditionally an exorcist will say the only treatment for this or the most effective treatment for this is, you know, an exorcist or someone who's going to deliver them. I mean, that's out there. It's fairly rare. What you can see when you open YouTube every day is the other level. Of demonic possession that is all around us and in fact is grabbing at our souls.
Hmm. Scary stuff. And most people like with the materialist worldview that so many Americans and just Western people have is that demons don't exist, spirits don't exist, God doesn't exist. It's all the things that I can see in front of me. I know this pen is real because I'm holding it right here.
But then they'll fight like cats and dogs on YouTube. Why? You know, it's that's it's a it's a performative contradiction. All that's all that's important is what exactly? What is important? What makes it important? So yeah.
49:25Why we don't wrestle against flesh and blood
Yeah. Well my the biggest thing I usually bring up with people like that is, well, how do you think the universe got started? May maybe we can, you know, for forget about specific religions or whatever, but like how do you think this all came about? Do you think we're we're just randomly here and able to speak to each other? I mean I am speaking to you, another intelligent being, on my computer, through a camera, through these different cables, all of these things. Incredible intelligent design. It doesn't even make sense. And of course, that's this is just like a microcosm. You think about the whole world, all the vast oceans, all the fish, everything. How can a normal person explain that? You can't say the Big Bang.
Yeah, yeah. And David says, you know, basically, this you know, things are too wonderful for me. What does that mean? It means I can't I can't comprehend this enormous world. And so I that's what cognitive science is about. I turn it into little chunks and I take those as they come. The you know, one of the most radical things that the Apostle Paul says at the end of the book of Ephesians is we don't battle against flesh and blood. Now, what does he mean by that? It means that we're always dealing with the spiritual powers that are working through other people. And in fact, every step towards greater health and agency and freedom is a step away from some demonic control over the way that you deal with other people. And so when Jesus says, A new commandment I give you, that you love one another, that's really the project. And of course he exhibits it on the cross when he says, you know, Father forgive them for they don't know what they're doing. I mean, it's essentially the same thing that Paul is saying in we battle not against flesh and blood.
Because quite clearly Jesus looks at those who are hanging him on a cross, and he basically says, They're running a program that someone is running through them, and they meet need to be delivered from it. And I'm going to let them crucify me because this is a key part of that deliverance. And so then you have the Roman the Roman guard saying, surely this man is a son of God. Well, and how a Roman would say that, he wouldn't say that as a Jew. You know, this is, you know, it's the same reason Pilate was n it's the same reason Jesus made Pilate nervous. Because Pilate was there and expecting Jesus to beg and plead and bargain for his life, and Jesus basically says, No, I understand everything that's happening here. And that that really disturbed Pilate. And then, you know, his wife has a dream and you know, Pilate's Pilate doesn't want anything to do with it, but he's trapped by all of the demonic presence or, you know, all the demonic agendas around him. And again, when people say demonic possession, you don't look at Pilate. He's not writhing in the floor or speaking in other languages, or he's not, you know, not doing anything like that. But he's definitely bound in by demonic forces.
Dang. Mm. Yeah, you articulated that very well. I see that all the time when there's someone has some kind of emotional reaction to a word or a concept. And like you said, they start running a program. I think of it as they it get stuck in a loop. They just th once you do something to start the loop, they just now the loop continues. So...
My answer for everything are, all that's what leftists are like, or that's what conservatives are like. It's our answer for everything. That's a really that's a really powerful tool where you can organize the world into two parts based on all of this, but it's also a really that it doesn't really work that well.
Well, and it's almost I'm seeing the parallel between the materialist view we were talking about of just trying to instead just generalizing things and because it's it'd be too difficult and too nuanced to say, well, everyone has a different perspective and well I should listen to each person and really hear them out. Like, no, I'm just cause now you're a racist. You're a you're a radical fascist. Like, okay, all right, fine. I guess we just can't talk.
It could okay, did it...
54:26Estuary's four-step conversation protocol
Yeah. Now so we've been talking about demons and maybe part of your fight against demons or the way the modern world is operating is this group that you have, or rather many groups, this organization, Estuary. And I'd like you to talk a little bit about Estuary and also specifically you mentioned there's a protocol. For those. What have you found is the s successful protocol for these groups?
Well, we have a little Estuary protocol. And so if you go to an Estuary group, the it's there's a ritual and we do it every time. You sit everybody in a circle, probably eight to ten people. It's about optimal. And you know, there's nothing new here. You go around the circle first, everybody introduces themselves. Who are you? So that's the person. And then everybody in the group who wants to, nobody has to, but pitch an idea to the group. Something you've been thinking about. Something, maybe it's an intellectual idea, something you've been thinking about. Maybe it's something personal, something in your own life. Maybe it's something contextual, something going on around you at home or in politics, in your workplace, in your school, what have you. Or maybe it's something estuarial, something that has to do with the group itself. Just pitch an idea to the group. Get three, four, or five of those things sort of on a virtual table in the middle. Then the third round is have everybody in the group point to something that has been pitched. Other than what they pitched. And then the facilitator sort of tallies it up and finds the consensus of the group where they want to start talking. And then you play. So it's person, pitch, point, play. And then you just have the conversation for hour and a half, two hours. That's the whole thing. And what we found is that most often, not always, you can you can torpedo a group if someone doesn't know how to participate in something like that appropriately, but then you just have a conversation about what the group wants to talk about. And you know that the group is going well when usually things will start up here sort of at the intellectual level, but when they start to come down and get personal. And if you do this, I've been doing it every Sunday morning at nine o'clock before our worship service at eleven. The group begins to trust each other. They begin to know each other. They begin to experience community. It begins to become a very useful workshop for whatever anyone in the group sort of is kind of working on themselves. And it's you know, there's nothing secret about it. There's no agenda to it. It isn't about making this or creating that. It's just people really the thing we smuggle in is it is about listening. Because of course, if you have a group of eight people, you will be spending way more time listening than talking. And if you can learn to listen, well then you can begin to find the pleasures of learning and being knit together and hopefully learning to love each other with words. So that's really what it's about.
57:48Why in-person community beats online
Yeah. Yeah. I know you guys are hosting a conference next year. I'll make sure to make that one. And I think it's more important now than ever that people start getting together more in person. And maybe this can be our final topic that like, why should people do things in person? Which it's kind of ironic that we're doing this podcast on online, but hopefully I'll interview you in person someday. Why is it more valuable to do things in person? Why go to church in person rather than just watch a YouTube video of a great pastor? Or why get in these Estuary groups in person rather than you could just do like an online Zoom call? What is the value of doing things in person?
Well, right now both of us are sort of being reduced to these avatars on a screen. And before we started the recording, we talked a little bit about ourselves to get a little bit of context. But the more context you can have, and you can only have this in person, the richer the whole thing is going to be. When you get the moment you get into the room, you are signaling two people about each other. And even though only a fraction of this gets we interact at the conscious level, because consciousness is very, it's very costly in that sense, because we can sort of only it's monofocal, we can sort of focus on one thing at a time. We are, you walk into a room by a thousand different elements of who you are and how you behave, I will at a deep level unconsciously begin to create a map of who you are. And so in person, it's just way, way more bandwidth. And what that means is that the potential for community is far higher. Now, I, part of what I've been learning over the last nine years is just how much community you can create and enjoy online. And it was more than I thought it was. And that's been a pleasant surprise. But It's once you're in real life, things are at a whole different level. And again, it's not dissimilar to on one hand, it's great to be in the stands and cheer on your team as they're heading for the championship. It's a whole nother thing if you're on the team and have been sacrificing everything towards that moment. And if you somehow participate in the victory of the team. The meaning, the meaning level is so much higher. We have this tremendous capacity for vicarious engagement, which in some ways that's what we're doing right now online. But in person, the level of participation is so much higher. And it's, that's why it's the potential is much greater. It's also riskier because there's just more in play. But that's some of the difference between screen and in real life.
Yeah. No, I've witnessed that as well. Like you said, it's richer that you see the full person. You can th there's also just some aspect that you can't really quantify of like their vibe or their spirituality, just like small things that you can't really pick up, their their full body language, all of that. So yeah, I totally agree. And Paul, I've got one last question for you here. And that is since we've been talking all about meaning and kind of where the church is at right now and what people are doing. What is your vision for maybe the US and the church? What do you hope to see?
1:01:27The future of the church in America
I'd like to see the church able to once again engage more of the people in the culture than it has. If you look at churches long term in the United States, but also in other countries, it's there there's just really a boom and bust cycle. And, you know, the nineteen church attendance reached its peak over all of American history in the nineteen fifties and sixties. That was a peak. More than in the revolutionary days, more than in any day since, even though people have nostalgic ideas about churches on the frontier, et cetera, et cetera. More Americans participated in church in the fifties and sixties as a percentage than in at any other time. And we've been on the down side since then. It would be nice to see us be able to turn this corner. Don't know how. And I don't think there's one answer. I think the Orthodox are helping, I think. Other groups are are trying to figure out how to minister to the nation and that's the job of the church. And so, you know, right now we're using YouTube and the internet and but as I said, in real life it's far more important and it's fundamentally more enduring, but it's also much harder. 'Cause I can, you know sit in a n sit with a nice background and wear nice clothing and all we're doing is talking back and forth. We don't have a rich context of interrelated relationships where all kinds of mischief and good and bad can happen. So but the church I'd like to see the church figure out how to engage this culture and engage this country and encourage more and more participation in the formation of the body of Christ. So how we get there, I don't know. But and it's not just gonna be one thing. Like I said, I think the Orthodox, they're playing a part of it now. That's awesome.
1:04:04Where to find Paul VanderKlay and Estuary
But there's lots of other churches that are doing it too.
Yeah. Amen. Well thank you so much for coming on the show, Paul. This has been awesome. I really appreciate your time. And I've like I mentioned before the show, I've I have so much respect for you and what you do. Where can people find you online and connect with you?
Just look for Paul VanderKlay on YouTube. If you just type in Paul VanderKlay as it is right down here, you'll find me. And if you can't, you know, if can't find me, there's all these other little small channels that are around me. And we do live streaming and we get to know each other, get involved with Estuary, look for an Estuary group. Yeah, I'm around. I'm not that important to the whole thing. I'd much rather see the whole thing than just, a fandom or personality cult. So just figure out how to participate.
Yeah, I get that. Yeah. So everyone make sure to go subscribe to Paul's YouTube channel. And yeah, with Estuary, how many different states are you guys in? And how many groups are there?
It's hard to know. I my guess is there's about a hundred worldwide. So mostly in the English speaking world, Australia, Canada, United States, England, Ireland, Netherlands, Germany, Greece. There might be some in Greece, I don't know. The Estuary Hub, EstuaryHub.com has list of groups, but we're we're not terribly well organized at this point and we're we're working on that. But part of part of doing this has been yeah, it's been a labor of love of people. And we do have there are Estuary conferences. I'm hoping that in the next few years we'll get ourselves if you go to my channel and you look in the show notes, you'll find a variety of different links to some different things, but it's still not as easy to get into as I'd like it to be. But that's just sort of a difficult thing in a way analogous to the fact that while churches work really hard at their front door, there's really no substitute if you want to get into a church than to just start going every week and building relationships. That's really the way in. And the same is true for lot of things like Estuary and the online element called the TLC so...
Definitely. Yeah. So everyone go make sure to check out Estuary. The link will be in the description. And hopefully there's one near you or maybe there will be soon. So Paul, thanks so much for coming on the show. This has been awesome and yeah, I hope to stay in touch.
Thank you, Dan. Really good.
Of course.



