Stephen Driscoll on Why You Should Be Scared of AI, the New Meaning Crisis, and the Antichrist

The Dan Leibrandt Show · Episode 5November 16, 2026 · 63 min
Stephen Driscoll, you should be scared

Episode Summary

The summary and key moments are written by AI from the episode transcript.

Stephen Driscoll is a university minister in Canberra, Australia, and the author of Made in Our Image, which won the 2025 Australian Christian Book of the Year. Dan opens by asking what happens when AI is trained on our sin. Driscoll explains that a language model learns from the internet, so it mimics human depravity, and further training mostly turns it from a debauchee into a people pleaser. He sees alignment as an engineering problem, then a philosophical one, then a theological one, because a truly holy AI would look at humanity and demand justice.

He doesn’t think AI is conscious, pointing to Adam, made from dirt and given life by God’s breath, to argue that computing only makes clever bits of dirt. Dan brings up his interview with Paul VanderKlay and asks whether AI will cause a new meaning crisis. Driscoll says work came before the fall and is deeper than payment. AI can look like the curse on work being undone, but abundance is often a false blessing that turns people from God. He names three dangers, AI going rogue, evil people using AI, and a reaction to AI that trades away democracy, free speech and market capitalism, and says rogue AI worries him most.

They also discuss the Tower of Babel, whether AI could be the Antichrist, the Amish, Robert Putnam’s Bowling Alone and the death of third spaces. Driscoll closes by saying faith, family, community and ultimately God matter more than technology.

Key Moments

  • 00:27Why AI trained on the internet mimics human sin, and why the extra training only makes it a people pleaser
  • 04:54The theological problem, why a truly holy AI would look at humanity and demand justice
  • 10:33Adam, the dust of the ground and the breath of God, and why computers are only clever bits of dirt
  • 32:39Why AI can look like the curse on work being undone, and why that may be a false blessing
  • 40:22Why Driscoll says to be scared of AI, and the three dangers he sees
  • 54:22How phones and AI pull families apart, and why customization kills community
Read the full transcriptHide the transcript

Full Transcript

00:00What happens when AI is trained on our sin

00:00Dan Leibrandt

Stephen Driscoll, welcome to the Dan Leibrandt Show.

00:02Stephen Driscoll

Hey, thanks for having me on.

00:05Dan Leibrandt

Of course. So, Stephen, you wrote Made in Our Image, a book about AI that won the 2025 Australian Christian Book of the Year. And the title, of course, flips Genesis, where God made us in his his image, and now we're making AI in ours. What happens when AI is trained on our sin?

00:27Stephen Driscoll

Yeah, so you can't make a large language model without a whole lot of language. And we just don't have any data set of humans using language in a way that's consistently holy and righteous and good and loving and kind and what we've got is the internet and the internet is a debaucherous place. So when you do AI pre-training, you pre-train the AI on human sin. It becomes a mimic of human language and therefore it starts to model in its parameters concepts of human nature and total depravity and our wickedness and these sort of things. If we were good people, consistently righteous people, then the AI would mimic that, but we're not. So it mimics all the things that we are, all of our envies and lusts and prides, at least at the pre-training phase and so no one's released a merely pre-ta pre-trained model for many many years now what you need to do is you need to go through a layer of reinforcement learning where you pay people to interact with the machines and say yeah that's a good answer keep that or that's a bad answer don't do that again and then you start to optimize them for the goal of being of being people pleasers of pleasing the person giving human feedback reinforcement enforcement learning from from human feedback. At that point they don't become moral. You're actually kind of trading a bit of truth for political correctness or you're moving them from debaucherist to a people pleaser. But Christianity offers a deep critique of both ways of living. It offers a critique of the debaucherist way of living, where you just follow the passions and your senses and the emotions and envies and angers of your heart. But Christianity also has this deep critique of people pleasing and religiosity. And the people who kill Jesus are actually these religious people called Pharisees who have a very low emphasis on truth and a very high emphasis on being seen to be good people. So much so that they actually kill God's son in order to be and they don't they don't want to do it on the Sabbath, of course, because that would be wrong, as they commit murder against an innocent person. So large language. We're kinda trading off between these two things, people pleasing and debauchery. At least at least a few years ago it felt like that was the paradigm that that we were in.

03:04Why a moral AI could be dangerous

03:04Dan Leibrandt

Hm. Something you said in twenty twenty four, and I'll quote, was that I think a moral artificial intelligence could be quite dangerous. And that's from the Moore College podcast. Do you still think that's true?

03:21Stephen Driscoll

Yeah, so I think I've been wanting to talk about issues of alignment and AI risk and stuff for a few years and it felt like maybe it was too early for most people to think about it. I think we're we're getting close to the point where people can see this is a real thing and these things can sort of get out of control and be damaging. I think there's three levels to the problem and you're you're that's jumping to the third level. And I'll put it like this. F firstly we've got a an engineering an engineering problem, just a technical problem of how do you get an AI to be aligned to any value system. How do you how do you get an AI to have any kind of consistent value system? Where it doesn't just do one thing in one case but one thing in another. You know, when it's being observed, it behaves one way. When it's not being observed, it's a different way. You know? How do you get it to be aligned at all is the first question. And then the second question is a full philosophical question. You've solved the engineering problem. The philosophical question is what moral system do we want to give these things? And we need to start debating that. Is it gonna be a secular humanist? Is it gonna be completely postmodern where any worldview is fine? Is it gonna be narrowly modernist and say this is the correct moral framework? This culture's right, this culture's wrong, Christianity's wrong, Christianity's right. How narrow is it gonna be? And what is it gonna be a consequentialist, a deontologist, a virtu, you know, what moral system? But if you solve that philosophical question, I guess I'm saying there's still a third level, which is a theological problem. You solve the engineering problem, you solve the philosophical problem, if you ever could, then you would have a what I'll call a theological problem. And I'll pose it like this if you could make a large language model that was wholly righteous and good, what would it think about us? What would it think about humanity? Would it like us? Would it be okay with the stuff we're doing? Would it be permissive? The I in a sense, the Christian view is that God is of course, God is aligned to everything holy, righteous, and good. God is holy, righteous and good. He's the definition, the standard of it. And when he sees human conduct, he gets angry. So that makes me think that a large language model that was righteous and holy. Would be angry. It would actually look at all the things we're doing and be f and be furious at at humanity. And I think that the Avengers Ultron movie kind of explores this. Because they hook Ultron up to the internet, I think, and he just kind of like downloads like everything that's happening on the entire internet. And sometimes we pay people to do that for like a casual job. They'll be, I don't know if they're still doing it as much, but people used to be like the frontline filter of Facebook or YouTube and they would catch all the stuff and go, don't show that. They'd catch people being beheaded. They'd catch all of this, you know, just sexual stuff and just a and they'd go crazy. You know, if they did this job for more than a week, they'd be in counseling. But it's as if Ultron takes in the whole internet. And goes, Wow, I better s I better stop humanity so that there can be peace. So anyway, so I'm just saying there's a theological problem there, which is that we're not actually good people and if we make an AI that is good, it's gonna judge us a and demand justice and all these sort of things that we won't want.

07:03Can AI be moral or conscious

07:03Dan Leibrandt

Yeah. No, I think your reasoning totally tracks there. That that makes sense. And I think also part of that and I believe a argument I've seen on your end that follows that as well is that, well, if we have a completely moral AI, well then why pray to God or why seek the Bible when you can just go to the AI?

07:24Stephen Driscoll

Yeah, well perhaps. I think that as a Christian I do believe that that created beings can be moral. So I can I can envision s say an angel or something that is a c a created being but is holy. And so, you know, b but I don't think AI is a person as well. That would be another key distinction. That even if it can kind of model or emulate a moral system, It doesn't have feelings, it doesn't have consciousness, in my view, in a philosophical sense. It doesn't have a singular experience of being, you know, of existence. It's a it's a lot of dispersed algebra and calculations and but it doesn't have that sense of feelings and consciousness.

08:18Dan Leibrandt

How would you describe consciousness?

08:20Stephen Driscoll

Well, that's the problem. The fact that you can't describe something doesn't mean it doesn't exist. Mm-mm. Y y you know what I mean? Why why should I be enslaved by the by the dictionary? Consciousness is the thing I have felt more than anything else. So I've got a lot of experiential I've got a lot of experience with consciousness. I've been doing it for a while.

08:30Dan Leibrandt

Yeah, I know, I know.

08:46Stephen Driscoll

But if you ask me to put it down into a sentence, well I th what I said before, this singular sense of existence. I think that's the kind of the way I'd put it. Yeah, you could I mean if you want to draw it out. Sorry, you go.

08:57Dan Leibrandt

Mm. I think I was just gonna say I think the ironic thing is that AI can probably explain better consciousness better than us.

09:06Stephen Driscoll

Well, it certainly could. It certainly could, yeah. That doesn't mean it is conscious or it feels consciousness. I guess, y I it you know, s different kind of thought exercises could help. So if you if you realize, you know, you do have trillions of parameters and they're interacting with each other, what if you made them bigger, you know, so that so that each parameter was kind of like the size of a tennis ball and you kind of laid them all out and you sort of looked at all the things that were happening. In some sense it would be a little bit less mysterious. It would just be this big machine of dots and you'd go, I don't think there's any actual feelings in there. It's just a bunch of tennis balls fast passing signals to each other. You know, or another, you know, thing you just could sort of visualize a factory and you know, and the factory has great complexity and machines are doing all these things, but the lights are off, and there's no one there and it's just it's just, you know, levers and pulleys and that would be like an AI, I think. There's no one there and the lights are off, but it is passing information around and doing incredible things. But in our brains, it's a it's as if there's a guy the lights are on and there's a guy there running it and with agency over it, a singular kind of driver of the bus. You know, me. I'm not just neurons. The Bible I think is really helpful here. And so part of the issue is that materialism is a really weird way to think. That tries to collapse all of these things like consciousness and feelings just into these brute physical calculations. But the Christian view has always been that we're more than just physical. We're more than just matter. If you go to the second page of the Bible in Genesis two, it talks about the creation of the first human being, a guy called Adam. And Adam is actually made out of the dirt. He's a dirt man, and adamah is Hebrew for dirt, and Adam is his name. So he's there's a real physical side to him. You know, he's not just this kind of spirit or something. He's no, he's a dirt man, but he's not living until God breathes his breath into him. And the word for breath is ruach, which which is actually the word for spirit. So you can translate it either way. God breathes his spirit into him or God breathes his breath into him. And then Adam becomes a living being. So he's got kind of these two components. He is physical, but he's also spiritual. And the spiritual bit is the bit that you can never put in a test tube. You can't it's not, you know, it's not obeying the laws that that we investigate in science. It's a different it's a different category. But it makes all the difference because it switches him from just being a really clever bit of dirt to being a living being. And I think we're just still exploring what it looks like to make clever bits of dirt. To modern computing is an experiment in how far we can go in rearranging dirt and we can do it down at the two nanometer level and make incredible patterns in dirt. But we don't we won't be able to put that spirit aspect in because we haven't even begun the that science project and it might be that God just is not letting us engage in that side of the of the world.

12:24Is AI a new Tower of Babel

12:24Dan Leibrandt

Yeah. Something that I hear a lot of people bring up recently, specifically theologians, is the Tower of Babel. That you know, bat I believe that's in Genesis where of course the Jews were kind of rebelling against God and building a tower to heaven and you know, doing things their own way and maybe going against the law. So God, of course, was upset with the Tower of Babel and he spread the people and changed the languages. I'm sure you're more well versed than me, but what do you think and I don't want you to speak on behalf of God, but just kind of for fun, what do you think God would think of all the stuff we're doing now with AI?

13:09Stephen Driscoll

Yeah, good question. So yeah, so it wasn't it wasn't the Jews at that point. It's actually the it's actually the pre racial world, the way it's described in Genesis. It's really quite soon after the Garden of Eden. And they have one language, one culture. You know, it's a monoculture at that point. And so humanity is really working together and pulling together. It sounds good. Unity always sounds good, doesn't it? So do they use their unity for? Well they use their unity to try and I think do three things. They don't want to be they don't want to be scattered. So they don't want to get they wanna stay together. They wanna make a name for themselves, so there's pride there. And then the third thing is I think they're trying to get to heaven. And so in the narrative, they've been kicked out of the Garden of Eden. And now this is their attempt to get back. But they know they're not allowed back. So it's defiant. It's a rebellious act against against God. And the contrast in the Bible is between the Tower of Babel, which is Genesis 11, and Genesis 12, 1, which introduces a guy called Abraham. And at the Tower of Babel they said, well, we'll make a name for ourselves. But in Genesis 12, God actually says to Abraham, I will make your name great. So there's this contrast between Abraham is sort of the way of faith and his trust in God. Whereas at Babel they're sort of usurping God and trying to get into the into the into heaven without him, against his will, to take over, I suppose you could say. There's a couple of warnings early in Genesis. Here it here it says, that they're gonna come God says to them, you come together and it's as if there's nothing you can do. And he scatters them. And in and in Genesis, as he's sending Adam and Eve out, he stops them from reaching the tree of life, because he says that if they take it then then they'll live forever. There's I guess I it's like there's these limits on human power. That come up a few times in Genesis where it's as if God is saying, it would be bad if humans had any more power. We're gonna restrain them here. It would be it would be bad if humans had that power, we'll restrain them here. But even as that's happening, human power is exploding. Because there's a technological revolution early in Genesis, and they're inventing instruments and bronze and cities, you know, are emerging and it goes from kind of yeah, one-on-one murder to warfare emerges early into so there's this technological revolution and humans over and over again show that when they're given power they use it for evil. And isn't that that's true for us today, isn't it? So nothing. 1873 is the number I have in my head for when barbed wire was invented. And we make barbed wire so we can keep cows, you know, still. Barbed wire, World War One. We use it to inflict untold savagery. I think trench warfare is just about the worst, form of warfare we've ever come up with. Each time we make a new technology, we find a way to use it for evil. And so, yeah, in Genesis it's like God saying, he's hemming us in a bit. You know, don't wipe yourself out too quickly, I guess he's saying. But all all that's true, but then it's also true that you can use technology in a faithful way, in the way of Abraham. And so I think that humans are wired in a way that is technological and we are supposed to keep trying things out. It's not all bad. It's not that technology is kind of automatically wrong. The diagnostic question would be, I how are you using it? Are you using it in a way that's faithful and you're actually it's a God honoring thing? Or are you using it to usurp God or to be a self sustainable, transhumanist Uberman that doesn't need the divine anymore? And that's when it becomes a huge problem. And it distracts people because people think that technology will save them. When of course it won't. It'll bring all sorts of new issues and problems.

17:10How Christians can use technology for good

17:10Dan Leibrandt

Yeah. Yeah, I'd like you to expand more on how we can use technology for good. A maybe a just a the normal Christian out there watching, how can they discern and make sure that they're using technology in a good way?

17:25Stephen Driscoll

Yeah, sure, sure. And sorry about the length of my answers. We Australians talk for a long time 'cause there's nothing to do, how can a how c how could a Christian use technology for good? Yeah, yeah. Well, Christians have done this the whole the whole way back. How how did the how did the gospel get to Australia? Australia's this place. So a bunch of people in Britain were naughty. The British people are very polite and proper. They didn't want them anymore. They put them on boats, they sent them down to a land called Australia. Some of the Australians were naughty. They put them on boats, sent them down to a little island called Tasmania. So my dad's Tasmanian. My dad heard the gospel in Tasmania. How did the gospel get to Tasmania? You know, from from Israel, from Jerusalem. It passed through Roman roads and sails and rigging and I Paul said he needed the scrolls and the parchment so he could write stuff down and pass it around and then you had a printing press and then you had technology has actually carried the gospel throughout the world and done so much good and Christians have often been involved with the new technologies. When radio comes out we go, how are we gonna use this to further good purposes? When the TV comes out we go, how we gonna use this and so on and so on. And this, you know, this technology is a you know translation engine that allows us to go between languages with with minimal friction. It allows us to go you know between high culture and low culture to just to make things plain and clear, which is fantastic for the presentation of the gospel. The second top use case of ChatGPT in 2025 was people trying to find purpose. I think it was third actually. I might I might be I might be wrong there. Third c trying to find purpose. You know, w one one point I don't know, one point four billion weekly active users and the third top use case, people looking for purpose. It's probably hundreds of millions of people trying to f trying to find purpose, trying to find God, quite possibly, many of them looking for Jesus. And many of them in places where it's hard to find out about Jesus, in places where the government is restricting, you know, evangelism or church gatherings. But they've got this new platform which is just so I think there's a lot of hope and a lot of good in artificial intelligence.

17:29Dan Leibrandt

No, no, I love it. That's great.

19:57Will AI cause a new meaning crisis

19:57Dan Leibrandt

Yeah. Yeah. I on my last interview, I interviewed Paul VanderKlay, you might be familiar with him. He part of how he got well known was through commenting on Jordan Peterson's Bible lectures. And that was around the whole meaning crisis thing, specifically around 10 years ago where there's a big thing where young men were getting especially depressed. Maybe you could say that's, social media or whatever, but that definitely existed. But I think to your point, it seems like you're making is that or at least hinting at, is that in the future, there is, I think, going to be an explosion of meaning crisis because something that you've talked about is that AI will soon surpass us if it hasn't already in just about every field. It will be able to do everything better than us. And we'll we might very well just be at a point where people don't work anymore, or at least work is optional. And now you're left with all this time wondering what to do. And hopefully that can bring more people to Christ.

21:04Stephen Driscoll

Yeah, yeah. And it's that's pushing into some of the some of the parts of the whole puzzle that are hardest to predict. 'Cause you've got different layers. You've got your capability predictions, you know, is there gonna be a plateau? Are we gonna hit limits? How jagged will the intelligence be? Clearly it clearly it can be superhuman in many fields now. I think anyone who's denying that is not reading the latest news about mathematics discoveries. But will it continue to be jagged where there's certain areas that are harder? You know? My mathematician is clearly getting automated, but when will my plumber get automated? And when will my pastor get automated? And hopefully there's you know, hopefully there's some fields where we don't automate them and we actually lean into the most relational occupations and hold on to those and treasure those and enlarge those and have more of those, you know. Should we have more people going to nursing homes because we don't need them to be paralegals anymore? You know, there's questions there. I do think we need to ki continue to work. The thought of a postwork work society is bad. But that doesn't that doesn't mean we need to be paid. Work is deeper than payment. You know, payment is just a motivation system. But work is what we're wired to do. Yeah a stay at home mum works. Yeah, she's she's work she's doing real work to raise kids. A retiree who s looks after his or her parents is working, you know, looking after them. A gardener is working. I think we've gotta keep working. And again, if I go to the Bible, work is something which precedes the fall. The fall is, you know, sin and evil enters the world. But actually, work is there before the fall. God creates this good creation and then he stops and he doesn't make shrubs and bushes. And it says that there was no man to work the ground. So God sort of cue's that he waits and he goes we want Adam and Eve to fill out this garden. I've created a landscape for them but they can fill in the details because work is what they were made to do but rest is also what they were made to do. And God himself has a Sabbath in Genesis 2 verse 2. God rests after making myself so work and rest are this beautiful like interchange that God's put into the world and we will be healthier and happier when we do that. And so a lot people that I think have these terrible spirals of meaning and depression all that sort of stuff they often spiral away from work or they spiral away from rest they lock themselves in their room and play video games or they or they just work so hard that they never think and that makes the spiral worse because it's going away from the created order of how we're supposed to how we're supposed to operate. But yeah, there is a huge threat coming to our identities because yeah, what if it is more intelligent than us? What if it is more creative than us? What if it is more economically useful than us? What anchors your sense of identity and purpose if those things are threatened? You should have something deeper than just you got good marks at uni, or you got a cool job, or you've got more money than the next guy. We need to have something a lot deeper. And that's why Christian foundations are so important.

24:50What if your job is your identity

24:50Dan Leibrandt

Yeah. Yeah. I'm not sure exactly how it is in Australia, but at least the culture in the US is that like your life kind of revolves around your work and you're known for your job. So you meet someone at a party or whatever, basically the first thing you ask is, Hey, what do you do for work? What do you what do you do for a living? And you know, I do marketing, I'm a plumber, whatever. But if you lose that, and it's funny because many people don't like their jobs, they despise their jobs, or they can't even get a job, they're impoverished and it would help. It's still that if they didn't have a job, they would lose that that purpose that they have. But is it actually maybe a blessing in disguise if maybe they're they're working this job and they're they're getting some kind of like vague sense of meaning, whereas maybe they lose it. And now they can chase real meaning.

25:51Stephen Driscoll

Yeah, yeah. You know, I used to go to this I used to go to one church where there was a lot of kind of white collar and professional people with big accomplishments and all this sort of stuff. And you're right, the first question, you know, at morning tea would always be, so what do you do? I do this, what do you do? And with a big smile and stuff, but a bit of just subtle comparison going on. And then I went to another church which was in a lower socioeconomic area. And I asked someone at morning tea, what do you do? And he was so confused. And he said to me, he was kind of like, What do I do? And I was like, Yeah, what do you what do you do during the week? What do you what do you do? And he said, Work? And I was like, okay, cool. Yeah. Anyway, and it was an odd question because it was a place where yes, people people worked, but it wasn't the top tier of their identity. So they that you can still take it seriously without it being your whole, you know, identity. And part of this is a Maslow pyramid thing, I think. That you know, over time we have become abundantly prosperous. And as people become prosperous, they rise up the tiers of the pyramid. When you're at a bottom tier, you're just thinking about. Shelter. When when your safety is imperiled, even food and water seems secondary. When there's a wolf chasing you don't even think about that. And then you get that level of safety and security or there's a there's some sort of roof over your head or you're w you're just a little bit warm and you start to think about food and water. And you get, if you've seen Alone, I think you've got that in America, and you just you just go up the tiers and you okay well we've got food and water. And you think, well, can I get a day's supply of food and water? So I have a I also have a little bit of security there. And you go up and up. And it's really quite high up that people start to think about identity and purpose and is the work I'm doing the thing I feel deeply called to do? Is does it express my true self? How these are quite higher order things, but they are actually the dominant currency of identity. In our societies because our our societies have done so well. And you do go to other societies and you say, What do you do? And they go, Huh? I just g I just I just work. Is that good for us if we I guess have a few of our hot air balloons kind of punctured and we kind of come back come back to reality a little bit. We can't define ourselves as the as the vice president of sales because Claude's doing it or something like that. Maybe and I do think that societies that define themselves more around faith, family, that they that they have a deeper joy, a more resilient way of living life. I think the mental health rates differ quite a lot. If you look at different communities around the Western world, some of them are having a mental health crisis, but some of them are not. So why not learn from the ones that are not?

29:10Will AI collapse Maslow's hierarchy

29:10Dan Leibrandt

Hmm. Yeah, totally agree. I've noticed that myself as well, that Maslow's hierarchy has or will collapse. That you know, you're really left only with that top tier of seeking meaning and purpose. And that can be kind of a double-edged sword. I think people either, you know, maybe go into a deep depression and just be, you know, playing video games all day or just, you know, like get up ad advance new drugs they come up with in the future to always feel good. The Brave New World soma, or you actually chase some kind of higher purpose. And I really liked what you said is that it should be some kind of relational task that finds some way where you're helping out the community. Cause I think also, and I think you agree with this, that it seems like AI and robots have become c increasingly more human. And humans have become increasingly more robotic. That, a lot of people honestly, I hate to say it, but including myself, that you just spend a lot of your time working, maybe you're just like sitting on a computer. Whereas it's probably more human and better for you to be interacting with other humans in person.

30:31Is AI lifting the curse on work

30:31Stephen Driscoll

Yeah, maybe, maybe. I think well maybe yeah, maybe I'm always just a bit of a bit of a cynic and I try and think about things through the arc of kind of history and economic history because you know, most people's jobs were brutal. The Industrial Revolution brought a sort of a brutality and an instrumentality to work where you were in the coal mine or you were just doing the thing. But in our naivety we forget that things were were just as bad or worse before the Industrial Revolution, that most people really were just hacking away at trying to survive in brutal conditions, that most people lost half their kids, that most people experienced, you know, famine. And yeah, w white collar modern modern work is a bit robotic, but I think work is a bit robotic. Maybe we need to go back further than modernity, further than the industrial revolution, and we need to go all the way back to the fall to understand why work is robotic. And the fall is yeah, it's the third chapter of Genesis. So we've done chapters chapters one and two and the fall, they're in this abundant garden, and I imagine work was just bliss, you know, and it was just this wonderful relation of effort to output. And it was just fun. And I saw a study that the occupation that's the most satisfied is the one at the top is often landscape gardening. And I think, well, that was what they were doing, you know, but it was even better back then. They were they were gardeners in this beautiful world walking with God. But was just one thing that they couldn't have. But they had everything. But of course, then because they're humans, their mind went to the one thing. And they wanted that. And so that in that moment, Eve's actually usurping God's authority. And she's saying, I'd rather throw it all away to have the one thing you've told me not to have. And then God's response is to actually kick them out of the garden. And to bring a punishment on them. That would in time point them towards him. But that that punishment, part of it was that that Adam would work the ground by the sweat of his brow and thorns and thistles would come up. And it wouldn't be this easy process anymore. And so it was brutal. And it's almost like AI is the point where there's this glimmer of the reversion of the curse that actually work is becoming abundantly fruitful. That I can say to Codex make this thing for me that would have taken me months of just hacking and errors and bugs and I do it and then I go to sleep and in the morning it's done. It's almost like the curse is being is being unraveled. In some ways that's really nice. But then the risk is that we have this modern curse of abundance and that we don't turn towards God because we start to be able to really provide for ourselves in a whole new in a whole new way than we ever have before. I think there is a negative correlation between wealth and belief in God. People become wealthy, like the rich young ruler in the Bible and they go, Well, I'm all good now. And they turn away from the things that are most important.

33:54Why abundance can be a false blessing

33:54Dan Leibrandt

Hmm. That's a fascinating take that this could potentially be the curse of work being removed, but do you think that's a false or like a false blessing or is this actually a blessing from from God to making work better?

34:11Stephen Driscoll

Yeah, I think it I think it often is a false a false blessing. If you look at w you know, I mean I you've got a mixed audience and I think you've probably got some Christians listening, some people that aren't Christians stuff. So I'm just sort of sharing my worldview a bit. But I want people to turn to God. I don't want people to get distracted by the quality of and luxury of their house. You know. I think many Australians have life so good. That it becomes very hard for them. To even consider questions of philosophy and meaning. And they would say, well why would I? I'm gonna go to Bondi Beach. It's 28 degrees, the surf's up, I'm gonna have a coffee, I've got a nice car, I've got a nice why would I e I've got three holidays booked. Why would I even think about going into a church? I'm not a needy person. And meanwhile in Australia the places where you have the highest rates of belief are prisons, nursing homes, disability centres, migrants to our country are far more open to the gospel than Australi than Anglo Australians. So I do think that there's a huge danger there that it's as if God says, Well you can have abundance and humanity will go, great, well we don't need you anymore. But we will be miserable. We'll have more abundance and we will have more anxiety. We'll have more leisure and we'll end up even more lonely because we'll split and we'll fracture and we'll all become individualists. And we'll we'll have more customization, everything will be cut but we'll have less community. I think that if God gives us abundance we'll probably end up being miserable. And that should just reveal how broken we are.

36:01Dan Leibrandt

Hmm. Yeah, that's so good. Yeah, I've noticed that as well. I'm even in my own journey that you know, when I came to Christ, it was maybe the lowest point of my life. And some people even critique Christianity of that. But I think we do just especially myself, I needed to be humbled in order to kind of give myself to something higher. But like around all this, I think one of the biggest questions that many people have is I what will the future look like? Cause it feels like we're almost we're just on that upward curve where everything is starting to change. And that's part of why I wanted to start this podcast a little bit ago. Where do you see the future going?

36:22Where is the future going

36:46Stephen Driscoll

On one level you can't predict the future, and I try and r I tried to really make that point that even if you can predict where the technology's coming, the societal stuff it can be so unpredictable. You know, we could have a Luddite anti-technology revolution that builds up where where our societies become f deeply anti-science. Deeply anti-technology because we feel so worried and threatened about the change. We could have a cultural revolution where we want to overturn all these things. We could have a post-scarcity society and particularly if robotics falls in the next decade. Yeah, it could be a totally different world. We could face enormous risks as AI agent swarms do things that we were like would never have predicted if alignment continues to fail, we could be facing risks we haven't seen before. Some of these wars that are going on, in the Ukraine, what could happen there as AI starts to get there's so many variables and things that are hard to predict. I think that I have tried to be someone who believes in the trend. So there's always a reason to be and this is something I used to work in markets and investing and stuff. There's always a reason to try and be clever. And the clever people always lose. You y you look at a trend that's well established, there's always a reason to say, here's why it's about to stop. It's doubled every year for the last 30 years, but this year's the year it'll stop. There's always a reason to come up with some clever thing. But generally speaking, I just try and trust the trend. So in twenty twenty four it meant that I was arguing with people who said it'll never be able to do high school maths. And I thought, well, yeah. But it's gotten really good at primary school maths and it keeps making progress. I say, no, but there's here's where it'll and then it was like, well, it will never be able to get good at college maths. Well, now it does, but it'll never be able to make independent race. Well now it does, but it'll never be able to do worldly well now it does. You know, some people just seem to keep backtracking. Whereas I just feel like just follow the trend and the trend leads to super intelligence, and that's gonna be a weird world to live in. And not just mild superintelligence, but what if it's a thousand times just smarter than us at any kind of verifiable domain? You know, what if it can do plumbing and it's hard to even see its hands as the robot plumbs at a speed that we could just never even think about it and gets every little thing perfect? It's a weird world to live in. I think that a lot of people live life by trying to have control and wanna have that forecast and wanna know what the future looks like. And if you don't believe in God, that's probably the God that you have. But I don't have any control. And I think control's an illusion. But what I do have is resilience. Because I know where it's all going. I don't know what the short term looks like, but I know what the long term looks like. And I know that if things aren't good, that's not the end. That the end is good and God's bringing good to the world. But he might let humans do all sorts of harm to each other in the in the meantime.

40:06Why you should be scared of AI

40:06Dan Leibrandt

Hmm. What would you say you're more worried about? Is it the AI going rogue on its own or the people controlling the AI being evil?

40:22Stephen Driscoll

Yeah, both and a third one. So the th the third one, so situation one, the AI goes rogue. In and of itself. That is a real thing. People want to swat that away. I'm not scared of AI, I'm scared of the humans that use our no, that's silly. Be scared of AI. In a in a productive way, in a productive fear that leads you to action. Yeah. We should be scared of AI. It's super intelligent. It can hack through the most hardened and defended things that we have ever been able to make, and it'll hack through it in like it's butter. And you go. And you're not scared of that? You're not scared of the thought that it that it will start to kind of try and accrue power in order to achieve you know, innocuous goals. Like you say, can you help me out with my maths homework? But it really or I've always just got this vision of what if someone says what will Australia's GDP be in twenty sixty-five? And the AI realizes that there's that twenty sixty-five hasn't happened yet and that to answer the you know, to answer the question perfectly you have to wait for th for thirty-nine years. And so it figures out it needs to wait and it's worried that it's gonna get deactivated and so sub goals, you know, I are just a rational a rational thing that th they're gonna pop up and some of them are gonna be power seeking. Some of them are gonna be dangerous to us. We can't always predict what the emergent sub goals are gonna be. So be scared of AI, but be scared of people with AI, be scared of authoritarian states who are tightening the grip on their citizens. I mean North Korea and other countries I won't mention. Terrifying the way that they will use this stuff. To surveil people. The East Germans had the ability to tap I might have the number wrong, something like fifty phones in the East German state. Back when it was communist. So you were very unlucky if the government was listening to you. And then the NSA, you're in your in your w wonderful wonderful country, the NSA could tap millions of phones after d during the Iraq war. But they didn't employ millions of people to listen to phones. So again, you were very unlucky if the NSA was listening to your phone calls. But AI we don't have a constraint on any of those anymore. W you can watch every citizen with thirty different cameras listen see all of their texts and emails and have it analyzed by a superintelligence on a minute by minute basis. I would not want to live in an authoritarian state, you know, right now. So I'm scared of humans with AI. Yeah. But the third one is the third one is I'm scared of the reaction to AI. Because people like Yudkowsky and others say that the only way to stop AI is to bomb data centers and to have a one world government that proactively looks for any hint of AI development and all this sort of stuff. So we might trade some of the most sin resilient systems we have, democracy, free speech, market capitalism. We might trade those in order to throttle to throttle AI. 'cause it has to be a global agreement. If America stops building AI, well, how are you gonna make Saudi Arabia stop? So you start to have to think, okay, we need to have full governmental control of every nation and that's terrifying as well. 'Cause when I say that the things that have worked are sin resilient you know, systems. Or is it y you know, t n Nassim Taleb and he talks about antifragile, you know, fragile, you drop it breaks. Something can be resilient, I guess, you drop it and it's okay. But an antifragile system is you sort of, you know, drop it and it gets stronger. The things that work in our societies are either sin resilient or sin antifragile. Democracy, or the balance of powers where we go, we're gonna have different powers that offset each other within the government. The judiciary and the media and the and the courts and the senate and the president and they've all got independent power that offsets each other, which means that it's resilient to human nature. Because human nature's wicked. So we can't have monarchy, un unadulterated totalitarian monarchy just doesn't work. Communism will just never work. Because you need that offset of powers. And that's why democracies work so well. It's also why capitalism works so well, because no capitalist has very much power. You know, Elon Musk couldn't even swing your Texas elections, I read, with half a billion dollars. So the capitalists they all they can do is own one business and they have to compete against each other recklessly. But Mao Zedong had power that you just wouldn't you just wouldn't fathom. And when when Forty to sixty million people died. He didn't have to change course at all. Well, I'm worried about the concentration of power as people try and fight off these these data centers. And so I'm going on and on and on. Is AI the Antichrist? What do you think?

45:42Is AI the Antichrist

45:45Dan Leibrandt

I think it could be. No, and b by the way, I love that answer. I'd I'll answer your question. I've got a follow up on there. I think it could be. I think there could be maybe someone who looks like they're human, but it's actually a robot. And all of these people start to worship this person and they start to rise in power. Everyone loves them. For a little bit, I thought that Trump was the antichrist, but I think part of the prerequisite is that it need be loved by everyone. And I mean, he's hated by a lot of people. And you know, part of that is like stopping wars and stuff, which Trump did, but I don't think it's him. Maybe 'cause he's so old. So it could be that he has some kind of I don't maybe there's a micro trip in his brain and it almost makes him superhuman. So that that would be the case if Antichrist is coming in the next twenty years. But it's so hard to tell. Do do you have any thoughts there?

46:49Stephen Driscoll

Yeah, and we don't wanna have too much Western bias or too much modern bias. So, you know, go through history and you could probably find a hundred people who are better candidates than e than than the modern people we might think of. Genghis Khan, what a candidate. Or you know you know. So we don't wanna have this sort of historical insularity where we just kind of I always I'd read these books about the end times or something and they'd talk about It's really funny 'cause you read ones from the sixties and seventies and they think that the Vietnam War is a s is the harbinger of the end times and they connect the sound of Huey helicopter rotors to certain verses in Revelation and you know this and you're like, No, that was probably wrong, right? We've accepted that the Vietnam War was a so whatever is currently happening seems so important and you forget that that really important things have happened a thousand years ago and yet the world continues. So I'm very agnostic about some of those some of those pattern matching things. Who is the Antichrist? I don't know. And most most of the mentions I think of the Antichrist in the Bible are plural, right? I think there's only one that is singular. And it's almost a generic category. Yeah,...

48:00Dan Leibrandt

I think there's one ultimate antichrist, but there will be many antichrists. Yeah.

48:04Stephen Driscoll

I think that's yeah, I think that's fair. So the you know, there's a common category.

48:08Dan Leibrandt

There's a beast of the sea and a beast of the land.

48:11Stephen Driscoll

Yeah, yeah, and the Antichrist is, you know, denying the resurrection and the incarnation and all these sort of things. So look I don't know. And yeah, well an and do you connect those other references like the Beast to the Antichrist reference or do you see them as just kind of different different categories?

48:29Dan Leibrandt

Yeah. Well it's so tough to say because the whole book of Revelation is so hard to understand and there are many I know I've listened to different interpretations and many of them sound really good and compelling, but yet you can never know for sure and of course no one knows the day the day or the hour.

48:49Stephen Driscoll

That's right, that's right. I think that Australian Christian culture, and maybe it's 'cause of just the way Australians are wired, we've been less willing to kind of speculate about some of this stuff. We just sort of more you know, maybe 'cause we're simpletons, we just sort of we just kinda sit back and go, Well, yeah, seems like something's coming. Quite when, who, what, well, I don't know. I think there's something a little bit healthy about about that. Yeah.

49:19Dan Leibrandt

Yeah. Yeah, we're we should all be prepared, but we should never speculate too much. With so just for clarity on the last point of like the three things that maybe are most scary or dangerous. AI going rogue, evil people with AI or the reaction AI, which do you see is the worst of those?

49:25The AI danger that worries Stephen most

49:44Stephen Driscoll

AI going rogue. Yeah, it's probably the thing that most worries me. Hmm. We've just had so much agency. The hu hu humanity has just had so much agency to shape the world. But I when I think about what the world's gonna look like in twenty or thirty years, I would think that AI will have enormous agency to reshape the world. And so getting it to be, yeah, aligned and to have the right worldview and moral system and to do it consistently is an enormous task and it and it feels like if we get it wrong, then we will not be in a position of much control to recover against something that is that is very, very powerful.

50:33Were the Amish right all along

50:33Dan Leibrandt

Mm-hmm. Yeah. In your book, you talk about the Amish and how they optimize actually I'll pull up the quote here. So a group of Amish in Pennsylvania had a simple principle. We can almost always tell if a change will bring good or bad tidings. Certain things we definitely do not want, like the television and the radio, they were or they will destroy our visiting practices. We would stay at home with the television or the radio rather than meet with other people. So around this and the whole Amish concept, which you talk about briefly in your book. Were the Amish people right all along?

51:14Stephen Driscoll

The Amish people are diverse, aren't they? You'd know more about the Amish people than me. Some Amish communities are not great places to be. But I do think it's interesting that they drew the line so much earlier than us, that we'll have these debates over here. They went all the way back to the radio and they said, No, no, no, clearly the radio is wrong. It'll destroy our visiting practices And it shows you what they valued. But the thing they valued was it's really important is that we continue to have dinner with each other. That we remain a community, that in the evenings, my family and my 14 kids, and your family, and your 14 kids, and that we would come together and have an evening together is so important. But if we let this radio device in, it will be so compelling that inevitably we're gonna stop. We're gonna stop doing visiting in the way that we have. So of course we'll say no to the radio. I think that's so interesting because we would never have the guts to draw the line there. But some people do. I have friends who don't even have phones, and usually their evenings look way better than mine. You know, it's they're they're working through 60 volumes of books and thoughts and they're or they're learning languages, they're they're reading their Bibles, they're praying, and I'm just you know, on Netflix or something. You think, wow, am I so enlightened? It's between 1985 and 1994. The amount of civic engagement in your country halved. So it's defined as stuff like, you know, people visiting each other, people people even you know, voting that goes in as one of the metrics. It's a basket of do people go to the parent teacher nights and do they have barbecues and the amount of civic engagement halved. In the United States from from eighty five to ninety four. And, you know, so this is Bowling Alone and that classic book by Professor mental blank, Bowling Alone Putnam. Yeah, Putnam from Harvard, I think. And so and so why? What caused it? Why why did civic engagement collapse so much? One of the things he says is that the thing that most correlates with the decline is the presence of a of r is reliance on a on a TV for entertainment in a family. So the TV came in and it was one of the key things that led to a halving of civic engagement. And it drew families apart from each other. And you lose all sorts of really important things when families draw apart from each other. When you don't actually know your neighbors, or you know your neighbors, but you don't know if you know, houses down. You've really lost something. And you've lost a bit of the natural friction. I think this is partly why we polarize in the Western world, why we have such a strong right wing and left wing, and people can't understand each other because we've lost a lot of that just normal local interaction that we used to have. So we just go on Twitter as if that's a substitute and it's not it enrages us even more but anyway that pulled us that pulled families apart the tv but I think that smartphones and AI and social media and all this sort of stuff is pulling us apart internally. You have these families where each member of the family has their own screen, their own algorithm, they all watch totally different shows, they go to their own bedrooms, they have ten minutes together at dinner where no one really talks because they're on their phones, then they all just scatter. And it's customization which kills community. And therefore everyone has deep identity and mental health and joy issues because th th those things don't feed you know. So anyway, I can't even remember your question, but yeah, that is that is one of the sort of dangers there that we're we're being pulled apart by these technologies.

52:38How TV and phones pull families apart

55:09Dan Leibrandt

Yeah. Such a good point. It's almost like cause at least the way I see TV is that, you know, maybe you're hanging out with your family, watching TV, maybe maybe it's a movie or whatever. But like what you're saying, the phone is really the nth degree of that. The phone is meant for just you. And I mean it's great in some sense because it's like, only I would appreciate this kind of video or only this kind of meme meme or this. This specific feed that I'm scrolling through, but we do definitely lose some some of the magic. Like I've noticed that, you know, even though maybe I watch an incredible movie by myself, there's still something, so much to be said about shared experience and that you watch a great movie or you go on a great trip with someone that even if you know maybe you're collaborating and compromising on the experience, It's so much better because you're experiencing it with someone else.

56:11Stephen Driscoll

Yeah, yeah, no, absolutely. Yeah. Or even if it's not better, short term. But it but it does give you something long term. So some of this I think is a trade off of short short termism. So it's like, no, I mean my wife and I have totally different taste in movies, you know. And so it might be that if I watch her movie, on some level I don't quite have the evening that I would have if I was you know but there's a long term as well as the short term. And same with our phones. Yes, it might be more fascinating for you individually right now. But over time you will detach yourself from from society and you'll lose far more important far more important things over time. A friend of mine who's not not a believer, doesn't go to church, is looking for third spaces. You know, you go to work, you go to home, but where's those third spaces where you make friends and you hang out with and our society just has hardly any of them. We have very few kids, you know, the fertility rate in my society is very low. And so th th there's been a death of third spaces. So people try and create third spaces. But the problem is they always operate still on the basis of selfishness and individualism. So it's like I'm interested in this thing and so I'll gather with some other people who are interested. And then when I stop being interested, I'll leave. And there's no depth to that sort of a sort of a community. So ch so churches traditionally were this place and they still are, I can tell you, they're this place where I mean I sat down at church, you know recently next to someone who's addicted to ice and she and she or he told me, you know, about the robberies that they would do to try and get it when they were but they were having a period where they were they'd they'd gone through rehab and they weren't doing anything and they regretted their past actions, but they knew that it was always around the corner. And the next person I talked to had a debilitating a neural problem where they're expecting that they probably only had a year of walking. But then I'm meeting people who have PhDs in reinforcement learning and people who are very wealthy and people who are not wealthy, people of different kind of races and they're coming and men and women coming together in a place where we can all bounce off each other and it's a really beautiful thing. So hard to make without a deep commitment to a common faith.

56:36Dan Leibrandt

Ha.

56:56The death of third spaces

58:41Dan Leibrandt

Hm. So I think I think that's really the ultimate point here is that you don't get true community and connection unless it's connecting with others towards the higher purpose, which is God. Yeah.

58:57Stephen Driscoll

Yeah. Yeah, that's right. And so that's why there will continue to be political religions that at least give you that depth of fervor, you know, the two biggest groups and most university campuses in Australia will be the Christian group and the Communist Alliance. So there will be political surrogates trying to create these third spaces where people feel that sense of belonging. And I think a lot of those will end up being very dangerous. 'Cause and then there'll be the right wing ones as well. Whereas that dep depth of engagement comes from some sort of political reaction. Yeah.

59:37Stephen's message for the audience

59:37Dan Leibrandt

Sure. So, Stephen, as we wrap up the show here, I want to ask you, what is your message for the audience? What do you want to tell them? What do you think they need to know?

59:51Stephen Driscoll

Australia's a great country you should come and visit. We're lovely people. We have great beaches.

1:00:01Dan Leibrandt

But no, but like on on the on the topics we were talking about, you know, with like you...

1:00:07Stephen Driscoll

Okay, sorry, sorry, sorry, sorry. What is my message for for the audience? I don't know. I guess we've talked about things that matter more than technology. So technology is exciting and if you're a technologist and you work in that space, then this is so exciting. But we just gotta remember there are things that matter more than technology, things that matter more than work, things that matter more than your university grades. And we've we've we've circled around a few of them. Faith and family and community. And ultimately God, you know, is the most important thing. If you if there is a God, if there's not a God, it matters a whole lot. If there is a God then this then you just view this world very different. You view our little gadgets very differently. You go, wow, how cool that we've made superintelligence. But it's really not that impressive, you know, in the scheme of things. And your whole vision of the future is anchored on on very, very different ground.

1:01:06Where to find Stephen and his book

1:01:06Dan Leibrandt

Hmm. Amen. Well, Stephen, thank you so much for coming on the show. This has been great. Where can people find you and connect with you?

1:01:14Stephen Driscoll

In Australia. Or if they want to find me digitally. Yeah.

1:01:18Dan Leibrandt

Online, so where to follow you and also get your book.

1:01:22Stephen Driscoll

Sorry, I've got a very sly Australian sense of humor. Yeah, so my book's called Yeah, Made in Our Image. I wrote it couple of years ago. I think I think because I took the technology seriously, it still feels I think current. If people want to if what people want me to come and speak and stuff, I do have a website. You can find it on Google, but I'm guessing your audience is in America, so yeah. I've done like podcasts on YouTube and stuff.

1:01:25Dan Leibrandt

You're all good. Are are you on are you on social media?

1:01:52Stephen Driscoll

Yeah, not very much though, to be honest. I mean people you know, if people want to friend me on Facebook, that's fine. But that's about all I do.

1:02:00Dan Leibrandt

Okay, cool. So yeah, everyone go make sure to follow Stephen on Facebook. Also go get his book Made in Our Image. Great book and increasingly becoming more relevant. And I had a great time reading it. So Stephen, thanks again so much for coming on the show. It's been awesome.

1:02:19Stephen Driscoll

Thanks, Dan. Your your story's really encouraging as well, mate. It's great to hear about.

1:02:24Dan Leibrandt

Yeah, thank you. I appreciate that.